Kraft Shannon, Patel Sapna, Sykes Kevin, Nicklaus Pamela, Gratny Linda, Wei Julie L
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, University of Kansas Medical Center, 3901 Rainbow Blvd, Mail Stop 3010, Kansas City, KS 66160, USA.
Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2011 Jul;137(7):670-4. doi: 10.1001/archoto.2011.51. Epub 2011 Apr 18.
To report survey results of members of the American Society of Pediatric Otolaryngology (ASPO) on the practice patterns of surveillance endoscopy and management of suprastomal granuloma (SSG) in children younger than 2 years with indwelling tracheostomy tubes and to review our internal practice patterns.
All patients younger than 2 years who underwent tracheotomy between 1996 and 2006 at a tertiary children's hospital.
(1) Retrospective medical chart summary and (2) ASPO-approved and -administered online surveys to the membership of a 14-question survey on indications for infant tracheotomy, indications for bronchoscopy after tracheotomy, and treatment preferences for SSG in this population.
Summary and findings of survey results and of data collected from medical chart review, including demographics, medical comorbidities, age at time of tracheotomy, indications for tracheotomy, frequency of bronchoscopy after tracheotomy, frequency of observed SSG, and interventions for SSG.
Seventy-five ASPO members completed the online surveys. Practice patterns varied for frequency of bronchoscopy: only as needed, every 12 months, every 6 months, and every 3 months were reported by 38% (n = 26), 25% (n = 17), 24% (n = 17), and 9% (n = 6) of ASPO members, respectively. Most important indications for bronchoscopy were preparation for laryngotracheal reconstruction and decannulation (100% [n = 65] and 92% [n = 60], respectively), bleeding (76% [n = 59]), and difficult tracheostomy tube changes (70% [n = 57]). Lumen obstruction of 25% to 50% and 50% to 75% by SSG would likely receive intervention (30% [n = 22] and 14% [n = 11], respectively) with skin hook eversion and removal being the most popular technique. We reviewed the medical records of a total of 201 infants who underwent tracheotomy at our institution (110 boys [54.7%]). Indications included ventilator dependence (32.2%), craniofacial anomaly (15.0%), cardiopulmonary insufficiency(15.0%), neuromuscular indication (15.0%), and subglottic stenosis (6.7%). Thirty patients (14.9%) were premature (mean gestational age, 27 weeks). Median age at time of tracheotomy was 4 months for premature infants and 3 months for term infants. Practice patterns regarding endoscopy and SSG management varied widely within our own institution. A total of 205 bronchoscopies were performed on 109 patients during the study period. At the time of first bronchoscopy 43 of 109 patients were noted to have an SSG (39.4%). Elective removal of SSG occurred in 20 of 43 cases (46.5%), and 9 of 20 patients were noted to have recurrent SSG at subsequent endoscopy (45%). In addition, of the 23 children who did not have intervention for their SSG, 15 of 23 had spontaneous resolution and no appreciable SSG at the time of follow-up endoscopy (65.0%).
There are currently various practice patterns for surveillance endoscopy and management of SSG in children younger than 2 years with indwelling tracheostomy tubes. Development of clinical practice guidelines on this topic may improve patient care and reduce unnecessary procedures.
报告美国小儿耳鼻咽喉科协会(ASPO)成员关于2岁以下留置气管切开管儿童的监测性内镜检查及气管造口上肉芽肿(SSG)管理的实践模式的调查结果,并回顾我们内部的实践模式。
1996年至2006年在一家三级儿童医院接受气管切开术的所有2岁以下儿童。
(1)回顾性病历总结,(2)对ASPO成员进行经其批准并管理的在线调查,该调查有14个问题,涉及婴儿气管切开术的指征、气管切开术后支气管镜检查的指征以及该人群中SSG的治疗偏好。
调查结果以及从病历回顾中收集的数据的总结和发现,包括人口统计学、合并症、气管切开时的年龄、气管切开术的指征、气管切开术后支气管镜检查的频率、观察到的SSG的频率以及SSG的干预措施。
75名ASPO成员完成了在线调查。支气管镜检查频率的实践模式各不相同:分别有38%(n = 26)、25%(n = 17)、24%(n = 17)和9%(n = 6)的ASPO成员报告仅在需要时、每12个月、每6个月和每3个月进行一次支气管镜检查。支气管镜检查的最重要指征分别是为喉气管重建和拔管做准备(分别为100%[n = 65]和92%[n = 60])、出血(76%[n = 59])以及气管切开管更换困难(70%[n = 57])。SSG导致管腔阻塞25%至50%和50%至75%时可能会接受干预(分别为30%[n = 22]和14%[n = 11]),其中用皮肤钩翻转并切除是最常用的技术。我们回顾了在我们机构接受气管切开术的201名婴儿的病历(110名男孩[54.7%])。指征包括呼吸机依赖(32.2%)、颅面畸形(15.0%)、心肺功能不全(15.0%)、神经肌肉指征(15.0%)和声门下狭窄(6.7%)。30名患者(14.9%)为早产儿(平均胎龄27周)。早产儿气管切开时的中位年龄为4个月,足月儿为3个月。在我们自己的机构内,关于内镜检查和SSG管理的实践模式差异很大。在研究期间,对109名患者进行了共205次支气管镜检查。在首次支气管镜检查时,109名患者中有43名被发现有SSG(39.4%)。43例中有20例(46.5%)进行了SSG的择期切除,其中20名患者中有9名在随后的内镜检查中被发现SSG复发(45%)。此外,在23名未对其SSG进行干预的儿童中,23名中有15名在随访内镜检查时SSG自行消退且无明显SSG(65.0%)。
目前,对于2岁以下留置气管切开管儿童的监测性内镜检查及SSG管理存在多种实践模式。制定关于该主题的临床实践指南可能会改善患者护理并减少不必要的操作。