Johnson F, Naunheim K, Coplin M, Virgo K
ST LOUIS UNIV,SCH MED,DEPT SURG,ST LOUIS,MO 63110. JOHN COCHRAN VET AFFAIRS MED CTR,ST LOUIS,FRANCE.
Oncol Rep. 1996 Sep;3(5):851-5. doi: 10.3892/or.3.5.851.
Strategies for the follow-up of lung cancer patients after potentially curative treatment are known to vary widely. The optimal regimen remains unknown. We investigated whether the age of the surgeon affects choice of surveillance strategy. The 3,700 members of the Society of Thoracic Surgeons (STS) were surveyed using a detailed questionnaire to measure how these surgical experts deal with lung cancer patient follow-up. Subjects were asked how they use 10 specific follow-up modalities during years 1-5 following primary treatment for patients with lung cancer (TNM stages I-III). Repeated-measures analysis of variance was used to compare practice patterns by surgeon age, as well as by TNM stage and year post-surgery. Evaluable responses from 768 STS members (21%) were received. Follow-up strategies for most of the ten modalities were highly correlated across TNM stages and years post-surgery, as expected. The pattern of testing varied significantly by surgeon age for only one modality (LFTs). Even in this instance, the absolute differences in surveillance strategies among age groups were small. This analysis indicates that the post-treatment surveillance practice patterns of surgeons caring for patients with lung cancer do not vary substantially with practitioner age. The data provide credible evidence that post-graduate education is effective in homogenizing practitioner behavior.
已知肺癌患者在接受潜在根治性治疗后的随访策略差异很大。最佳方案仍不明确。我们调查了外科医生的年龄是否会影响监测策略的选择。我们使用一份详细问卷对胸外科医师协会(STS)的3700名成员进行了调查,以了解这些外科专家如何处理肺癌患者的随访。受试者被问及在肺癌(TNM分期I-III期)患者接受初次治疗后的1-5年里,他们如何使用10种特定的随访方式。重复测量方差分析用于比较不同外科医生年龄、TNM分期和术后年份的实践模式。我们收到了768名STS成员(21%)的可评估回复。正如预期的那样,在TNM分期和术后年份中,十种方式中大多数的随访策略高度相关。仅有一种方式(肝功能检查)的检测模式因外科医生年龄而有显著差异。即使在这种情况下,不同年龄组监测策略的绝对差异也很小。该分析表明,照顾肺癌患者的外科医生的治疗后监测实践模式不会因从业者年龄而有很大差异。这些数据提供了可靠的证据,表明研究生教育在使从业者行为同质化方面是有效的。