McAdam W A, Brock B M, Armitage T, Davenport P, Chan M, de Dombal F T
Airedale District General Hospital, West Yorkshire.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 1990 Mar;72(2):140-6.
This paper describes experience in a modern district general hospital with a small desktop system for computer-aided diagnosis of acute abdominal pain, over a 12-year period involving 5512 cases. When compared with a baseline year (1973) in which unaided performance was monitored, during an initial study period (1974-76) the diagnostic accuracy of junior staff rose by between 10 and 15%. This higher performance level was then maintained for a decade (1976-86) despite changes in staff. The perforation rate among appendicitis cases fell from 27% to 12.5%, accompanied by a smaller fall in negative laparotomy rates. The saving in surgical bednights devoted to acute abdominal pain was approximately 15%, and the notional cost of resources saved during the first 6 years of operation was 120,000 pounds. Other hospitals have shown--in the short term--benefits similar to those obtained at Airedale District General Hospital. The long-term benefits of the system at Airedale reinforce the conclusions of the earlier short-term trials that a comparable system should probably be offered to all DGHs in the UK, not as an exercise in 'artificial intelligence' but as an effective continuing stimulus to good clinical practice.
本文介绍了一家现代化地区综合医院使用小型桌面系统辅助诊断急性腹痛的12年经验,涉及5512例病例。与监测无辅助诊断表现的基准年份(1973年)相比,在初始研究阶段(1974 - 1976年),初级 staff 的诊断准确率提高了10%至15%。尽管 staff 有所变动,但这一较高的表现水平在十年间(1976 - 1986年)得以维持。阑尾炎病例的穿孔率从27%降至12.5%,同时阴性剖腹探查率也有较小幅度下降。用于急性腹痛的外科病床占用率节省了约15%,运营头6年节省的资源名义成本为12万英镑。其他医院在短期内也显示出与艾尔代尔地区综合医院类似的益处。艾尔代尔系统的长期益处强化了早期短期试验的结论,即英国所有地区综合医院都可能应配备类似系统,这并非是“人工智能”的尝试,而是对良好临床实践的有效持续推动。