Department of History, Oxford Brookes University, Oxford OX3 0BP, UK.
Cult Med Psychiatry. 2011 Dec;35(4):536-45. doi: 10.1007/s11013-011-9233-z.
This article explores the development of psychiatric institutions within the context of British colonial rule in India, in particular during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Existing scholarship on 'colonial medicine' has tended to focus on colonial power and hegemony and the British endeavour to 'colonize the Indian body' during the nineteenth century. It is suggested here that reference to 'colonial' medicine and psychiatry tends to reify the ideology of colonialism and neglect other important dimensions such as the role of international scientific networks and the mental hospital as the locus of care and medicalization. From the later period of British colonial engagement in south Asia, people's right and entitlement to medical care and the colonial state's obligation to provide institutional treatment facilities received increased attention. As the early twentieth-century case of an Indian hospital superintendent shows, practitioners' professional ambitions went beyond the confines of 'colonial psychiatry'. He practiced in his institution science-based psychiatry, drawing on models and treatment paradigms that were then prevalent in a variety of countries around the globe.
本文探讨了英国殖民统治时期印度精神病院的发展,特别是在 19 世纪末和 20 世纪初。现有的关于“殖民医学”的学术研究往往侧重于殖民权力和霸权,以及英国在 19 世纪“殖民印度身体”的努力。本文认为,提到“殖民”医学和精神病学往往会使殖民主义思想具体化,而忽视其他重要方面,如国际科学网络的作用以及精神病院作为护理和医学化的场所。从英国在南亚的殖民后期开始,人们获得医疗保健的权利和应享待遇以及殖民国家提供机构治疗设施的义务受到了更多关注。正如 20 世纪初印度医院主管的案例所示,从业者的职业抱负超越了“殖民精神病学”的局限。他在自己的机构中实践基于科学的精神病学,借鉴了当时在全球许多国家流行的模式和治疗范例。