Knapik Joseph J, Graham Bria, Steelman Ryan, Colliver Keith, Jones Bruce H
U.S. Army Public Health Institute, Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD 21010, USA.
Aviat Space Environ Med. 2011 Oct;82(10):935-40. doi: 10.3357/asem.3082.2011.
Since the 1950s, the standard U.S. military troop parachute system has been the T-10. TheT-10 is currently being replaced by the newer T-11 system.
This investigation compared injury incidence between the T-10 and T-11 military parachute systems.
Participants were students in basic parachute training at the U.S. Army Airborne School (USAAS). Students performed their first parachute jumps with the T-11 and subsequent jumps with the T-10. Injury data were collected from routine reports produced by the USAAS. Combat loaded jumps and night jumps were excluded from the analysis since these were only conducted with the T-10.
There were a total of 76 injuries in 30,755 jumps for an overall cumulative injury incidence of 2.5/1000 jumps. With the T-10 parachute, there were 61 injuries in 21,404 jumps for a cumulative injury incidence of 2.9/1000 jumps; with the T-11 parachute there were 15 injuries in 9351 jumps for a cumulative injury incidence of 1.6/1000 jumps [risk ratio (T10/T11) = 1.78, 95% confidence interval = 1.01-3.12, P = 0.04].
Limitations to this analysis included the fact that the T-11 was only used on the first jumps among students who had likely never previously performed a parachute jump and that aircraft exit procedures differed very slightly for the two parachutes. Nonetheless, the data suggest that injury incidence is lower with the T-11 parachute than with the T-10 parachute when airborne training operations are conducted during the day without combat loads.
自20世纪50年代以来,美国军队标准的部队降落伞系统一直是T-10。目前,T-10正被更新的T-11系统所取代。
本研究比较了T-10和T-11军事降落伞系统的受伤发生率。
参与者是美国陆军空降学校(USAAS)基础跳伞训练的学生。学生们首次跳伞使用T-11,随后的跳伞使用T-10。受伤数据从USAAS的常规报告中收集。分析排除了战斗负重跳伞和夜间跳伞,因为这些仅使用T-10进行。
在30755次跳伞中共有76人受伤,总体累积受伤发生率为2.5/1000次跳伞。使用T-10降落伞时,在21404次跳伞中有61人受伤,累积受伤发生率为2.9/1000次跳伞;使用T-11降落伞时,在9351次跳伞中有15人受伤,累积受伤发生率为1.6/1000次跳伞[风险比(T10/T11)=1.78,95%置信区间=1.01-3.12,P=0.04]。
该分析的局限性包括,T-11仅用于可能此前从未进行过跳伞的学生的首次跳伞,且两种降落伞的飞机离机程序略有不同。尽管如此,数据表明,在白天无战斗负重进行空降训练操作时,T-11降落伞的受伤发生率低于T-10降落伞。