Murase Kenya, Tanki Nobuyoshi, Miyazaki Shohei, Nagao Michinobu
Department of Medical Physics and Engineering, Division of Medical Technology and Science, Course of Health Science, Graduate School of Medicine, Osaka University.
Igaku Butsuri. 2008;28(1):15-25.
We previously introduced a quasi-fractal dimension (Q-FD) to enhance breast cancer detection in X-ray mammography. In the present study, we evaluated the usefulness of this image feature for differentiating between benign and malignant masses using a support vector machine (SVM) with various kernels. The kernel computes the inner product of the functions that embed the data into a feature space where the nonlinear pattern appears linear. Q-FD was calculated using the method previously reported from the database of X-ray mammograms produced by the Japan Society of Radiological Technology. In addition to Q-FD, the image features such as curvature (C) and eccentricity (E) were extracted. The conventional fractal dimension (C-FD) was also calculated using the box-counting method. First, we investigated the SVM performance in terms of accuracy, sensitivity and specificity in the task of differentiating between benign and malignant masses by taking 5 parameters (C, E, C-FD, Q-FD and age) as input features in SVM. When using the linear kernel, the best accuracy was obtained at a regularization parameter of 50. For the polynomial and radial basis function (RBF) kernels, the best accuracy was obtained when the degree of polynomial and the width of RBF were 1 and 1, respectively. The accuracies were 0.746±0.089, 0.731±0.095 and 0.734±0.086 for the linear, polynomial and RBF kernels, respectively, when using C, E, C-FD and age as input features in the SVM. When Q-FD was added to the above input features, the accuracies were significantly improved to 0.957±0.045, 0.950±0.045 and 0.949±0.052 for the linear, polynomial and RBF kernels, respectively. These results suggest that Q-FD is effective for discriminating between benign and malignant masses and SVM is highly recommended as a classifier for its simple utilization and good performance, especially when the training set size is small.
我们之前引入了一种准分形维数(Q-FD)来提高乳腺钼靶X线摄影中乳腺癌的检测率。在本研究中,我们使用具有各种核的支持向量机(SVM)评估了这种图像特征在区分良性和恶性肿块方面的有用性。核计算将数据嵌入到特征空间中的函数的内积,在该特征空间中非线性模式呈现为线性。Q-FD使用日本放射技术学会生成的乳腺钼靶X线摄影数据库中先前报道的方法进行计算。除了Q-FD,还提取了诸如曲率(C)和偏心率(E)等图像特征。传统分形维数(C-FD)也使用盒计数法进行计算。首先,我们通过将5个参数(C、E、C-FD、Q-FD和年龄)作为SVM中的输入特征,研究了SVM在区分良性和恶性肿块任务中的准确性、敏感性和特异性方面的性能。使用线性核时,在正则化参数为50时获得了最佳准确性。对于多项式核和径向基函数(RBF)核,当多项式次数和RBF宽度分别为1和1时获得了最佳准确性。当在SVM中使用C、E、C-FD和年龄作为输入特征时,线性、多项式和RBF核的准确率分别为0.746±0.089、0.731±0.095和0.734±0.086。当将Q-FD添加到上述输入特征中时,线性、多项式和RBF核的准确率分别显著提高到0.957±0.045、0.950±0.045和0.949±0.052。这些结果表明,Q-FD对于区分良性和恶性肿块是有效的,并且强烈推荐将SVM作为分类器,因为其使用简单且性能良好,特别是当训练集规模较小时。