Fenner School of Environment & Society, Australian National University, Canberra, 0200, ACT, Australia.
Ann Bot. 2012 Jan;109(1):197-208. doi: 10.1093/aob/mcr263. Epub 2011 Oct 12.
Resprouting and seed recruitment are important ways in which plants respond to fire. However, the investments a plant makes into ensuring the success of post-fire resprouting or seedling recruitment can result in trade-offs that are manifested in a range of co-occurring morphological, life history and physiological traits. Relationships between fire-response strategies and other traits have been widely examined in fire-prone Mediterranean-type climates. In this paper, we aim to determine whether shrubs growing in a non-Mediterranean climate region exhibit relationships between their fire-response strategy and leaf traits.
Field surveys were used to classify species into fire-response types. We then compared specific leaf area, leaf dry-matter content, leaf width, leaf nitrogen and carbon to nitrogen ratios between (a) obligate seeders and all other resprouters, and (b) obligate seeders, facultative resprouters and obligate resprouters.
Leaf traits only varied between fire-response types when we considered facultative resprouters as a separate group to obligate resprouters, as observed after a large landscape-scale fire. We found no differences between obligate seeders and obligate resprouters, nor between obligate seeders and resprouters considered as one group.
The results suggest that facultative resprouters may require a strategy of rapid resource acquisition and fast growth in order to compete with species that either resprout, or recruit from seed. However, the overall lack of difference between obligate seeders and obligate resprouters suggests that environmental factors are exerting similar effects on species' ecological strategies, irrespective of the constraints and trade-offs that may be associated with obligate seeding and obligate resprouting. These results highlight the limits to trait co-occurrences across different ecosystems and the difficulty in identifying global-scale relationships amongst traits.
萌蘖和种子繁殖是植物应对火灾的重要方式。然而,植物为确保火灾后萌蘖或幼苗繁殖的成功所做的投资可能会导致权衡,从而表现在一系列共存的形态、生活史和生理特征上。在易发生火灾的地中海气候中,广泛研究了植物对火灾的反应策略与其他特征之间的关系。在本文中,我们旨在确定在非地中海气候区生长的灌木是否表现出其火灾反应策略与叶片特征之间的关系。
通过实地调查对物种进行分类,分为火灾反应类型。然后,我们比较了(a)专性种子植物和所有其他萌蘖植物,以及(b)专性种子植物、兼性萌蘖植物和专性萌蘖植物之间的比叶面积、叶干物质含量、叶宽、叶氮和碳氮比。
仅在将兼性萌蘖植物作为一个独立的群体与专性萌蘖植物进行比较时,我们发现叶片特征在火灾反应类型之间才会发生变化,这种情况是在大规模景观火灾后观察到的。我们发现专性种子植物和专性萌蘖植物之间没有差异,也没有专性种子植物和萌蘖植物之间没有差异。
结果表明,兼性萌蘖植物可能需要一种快速获取资源和快速生长的策略,以便与那些萌蘖或从种子中招募的物种竞争。然而,专性种子植物和专性萌蘖植物之间缺乏差异表明,环境因素对物种的生态策略施加了相似的影响,而不受与专性种子和专性萌蘖相关的限制和权衡的影响。这些结果突出了不同生态系统中特征共现的局限性,以及在确定全球范围内特征之间关系的困难。