Fukuda Yoshiharu
Department of Community Health and Medicine, Yamaguchi University School of Medicine, Japan.
Nihon Eiseigaku Zasshi. 2011 Sep;66(4):736-40. doi: 10.1265/jjh.66.736.
The "Health Checkups and Healthcare Advice with Particular Focus on Metabolic Syndrome" (Tokutei Kenshin Hokenshido) started in 2008. We conducted a quasi-experimental study to elucidate the effects of healthcare advice.
We used data from insured individuals who received health checkups in 2008 and 2009 under the National Health Insurance system, in all municipalities in Yamaguchi prefecture. We compared changes in the findings of health checkups in 2008 to 2009 between intervention subjects who received healthcare advice from 2008 and control subjects who did not receive advice. The control group was matched with the intervention group in terms of area, sex, age, and level of advice.
Data from 786 subjects in the intervention group and 1224 in the control group were analyzed. The following showed significant differences in the change in health checkup data between the intervention and control groups: body weight, -1.1 kg; BMI, -0.4 kg/m(2); waist circumstance, -1.1 cm; triglyceride, -6.7 mg/dl; HDL-cholesterol, +1.0 mg/dl; LDL-cholesterol, -2.4 mg/dl; GPT, -1.4 IU/dl; γGTP, -2.4 IU/dl. There was no significant difference in blood pressure, FBS, or HbA1c.
This quasi-experimental study demonstrated a moderate but significant effect of healthcare advice, although several items including blood pressure and blood glucose did not show significant improvement.
“特别关注代谢综合征的健康检查与医疗建议”(特定健诊保健指导)于2008年启动。我们进行了一项准实验研究,以阐明医疗建议的效果。
我们使用了2008年和2009年在山口县所有市町村的国民健康保险制度下接受健康检查的参保人员的数据。我们比较了2008年至2009年接受医疗建议的干预对象与未接受建议的对照对象之间健康检查结果的变化。对照组在地区、性别、年龄和建议水平方面与干预组相匹配。
分析了干预组786名受试者和对照组1224名受试者的数据。干预组和对照组之间的健康检查数据变化显示出以下显著差异:体重,-1.1千克;体重指数,-0.4千克/平方米;腰围,-1.1厘米;甘油三酯,-6.7毫克/分升;高密度脂蛋白胆固醇,+1.0毫克/分升;低密度脂蛋白胆固醇,-2.4毫克/分升;谷丙转氨酶,-1.4国际单位/分升;γ-谷氨酰转肽酶,-2.4国际单位/分升。血压、空腹血糖或糖化血红蛋白没有显著差异。
这项准实验研究表明,尽管包括血压和血糖在内的几个项目没有显示出显著改善,但医疗建议有适度但显著的效果。