School of Life Sciences, University of Westminster Department of Primary Health Care, University of Oxford, 115 New Cavendish Street, London.
Sociol Health Illn. 2012 Jun;34(5):730-45. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9566.2011.01409.x. Epub 2011 Oct 21.
Recently, Scambler and others have broadened the research agenda on stigma to include the wider meanings of stigma within society, and especially the role of identity politics e.g. gay liberation. Recognising that the categories 'homosexual' and 'depression' were socially constructed and stigmatised from the 19(th) and 20(th) centuries respectively, we draw on themes in conceptual models of coming out as gay or lesbian to sensitise our analysis to personal experiences of depression and the specific ways in which the condition is constructed. Thirty-eight narrative interviews with people in the UK in various stages of recovery from depression were analysed comparing themes to a 'coming out' framework. The applicability of coming out themes to understanding the construction of depression was evident. Themes included childhood difference; confusion; the depression closet; challenging stigma via the biology vs. nurture debate; re-casting depression as commonplace or even fashionable; contending with a shame-pride narrative; coming out and, finally, integrating the depression experience. By comparing 'coming out' themes with depression experience in detail for the first time, we illuminate how people understand depression, cope with and resist stigma, thus providing insights into the contemporary situation in Western societies for those facing depression.
最近,斯卡布勒(Scambler)等人拓宽了耻辱感的研究议程,将耻辱感在社会中的更广泛含义纳入其中,尤其是身份政治的作用,例如同性恋解放。我们认识到,“同性恋”和“抑郁症”这两个类别是从 19 世纪和 20 世纪分别构建和污名化的社会类别,因此我们借鉴了同性恋出柜的概念模型中的主题,使我们的分析能够敏锐地感知到抑郁症的个人经历,以及构建这种状况的具体方式。我们对英国各地处于不同康复阶段的 38 名抑郁症患者进行了叙事访谈,将主题与“出柜”框架进行了比较。出柜主题对理解抑郁症的构建具有明显的适用性。主题包括童年差异;困惑;抑郁壁橱;通过生物与养育的辩论来挑战污名化;将抑郁症重新塑造为普遍或甚至时尚的;应对羞耻-自豪的叙述;出柜;最后,整合抑郁症的经验。通过首次详细比较“出柜”主题和抑郁症的体验,我们阐明了人们如何理解抑郁症,应对和抵制污名化,从而为那些面临抑郁症的人提供了对西方社会当代状况的深刻见解。