Toomey Patricia, Hanlon Neil, Bates Joanna, Poole Gary, Lovato Chris Y
Faculty of Medicine, University of Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Rural Remote Health. 2011;11(4):1774. Epub 2011 Nov 8.
To help address physician shortages in the underserved community of Prince George, Canada, the University of British Columbia (UBC) and various partners created the Northern Medical Program (NMP), a regional distributed site of UBC's medical doctor undergraduate program. Early research on the impacts of the NMP revealed a high degree of social connectedness. The objective of the present study was to explore the role of social capital in supporting the regional training site and the benefits accrued to a broad range of stakeholders and network partners.
In this qualitative study, 23 semi-structured interviews were conducted with community leaders in 2007. A descriptive content analysis based on analytic induction technique was employed. Carpiano's Bourdieu-based framework of 'neighbourhood' social capital was adapted to empirically describe how social capital was produced and mobilized within and among networks during the planning and implementation of the NMP.
Results from this study reveal that the operation of social capital and the related concept of social cohesion are multifaceted, and that benefits extend in many directions, resulting in somewhat unanticipated benefits for other key stakeholders and network partners of this medical education program. Participants described four aspects of social capital: (i) social cohesion; (ii) social capital resources; (iii) access to social capital; and (iv) outcomes of social capital.
The findings of this study suggest that the partnerships and networks formed in the NMP planning and implementation phases were the foundation for social capital mobilization. The use of Carpiano's spatially-bounded model of social capital was useful in this context because it permitted the characterization of relations and networks of a tight-knit community body. The students, faculty and administrators of the NMP have benefitted greatly from access to the social capital mobilized to make the NMP operational. Taking account of the dynamic and multifaceted operation of social capital helps one move beyond a view of geographic communities as simply containers or sinks of capital investment, and to appreciate the degree to which they may act as a platform for productive network formation and expansion.
为了帮助解决加拿大乔治王子城医疗服务不足社区的医生短缺问题,英属哥伦比亚大学(UBC)及其众多合作伙伴创建了北部医学项目(NMP),这是UBC医学博士本科项目的一个区域分布式站点。早期关于NMP影响的研究显示出高度的社会联系。本研究的目的是探讨社会资本在支持该区域培训站点方面所起的作用,以及给广泛的利益相关者和网络合作伙伴带来的益处。
在这项定性研究中,2007年对社区领袖进行了23次半结构化访谈。采用了基于分析归纳技术的描述性内容分析方法。基于卡皮亚诺对布迪厄“邻里”社会资本框架进行了调整,以实证描述在NMP规划和实施过程中社会资本是如何在网络内部及网络之间产生和调动的。
本研究结果表明,社会资本的运作及相关的社会凝聚力概念是多方面的,其益处向多个方向延伸,给这个医学教育项目的其他关键利益相关者和网络合作伙伴带来了一些意想不到的好处。参与者描述了社会资本的四个方面:(i)社会凝聚力;(ii)社会资本资源;(iii)获取社会资本的途径;(iv)社会资本的成果。
本研究结果表明,在NMP规划和实施阶段形成的伙伴关系和网络是社会资本调动的基础。在这种情况下,使用卡皮亚诺的空间界定社会资本模型很有用,因为它能够描述紧密联系的社区机构的关系和网络。NMP的学生、教师和管理人员因能够获取为使NMP运作而调动的社会资本而受益匪浅。考虑到社会资本的动态和多方面运作,有助于人们超越将地理社区仅仅视为资本投资的容器或汇聚地的观点,认识到它们在多大程度上可以作为生产性网络形成和扩展的平台。