Department of Kinesiology, East Carolina University, Greenville, North Carolina, USA.
Adv Physiol Educ. 2011 Dec;35(4):416-20. doi: 10.1152/advan.00021.2011.
The "conventional wisdom" is that grades are related to class attendance, i.e., students who attend classes more frequently obtain better grades and class attendance dramatically contributes to enhanced learning. However, the influence of sex (female vs. male) on this relationship is understudied. Furthermore, there have been several studies examining the impact of attendance on course grades that challenge the conventional wisdom. To address these issues, we determined the effect of class attendance on examination scores for female and male students enrolled in our undergraduate exercise physiology class of 51 students (20 female students and 31 male students). The experiment was designed not to interfere with the normal conduct of the course. Attendance was recorded in each class, and, although regular attendance was encouraged, it was not required and did not factor into the final grades. The final grade reflected the average days of attendance for female students only. Specifically, female students earning a grade above the class average attended 89 ± 4% of the classes; however, female students earning a grade below the class average attended only 64 ± 6% of the classes. In sharp contrast, there was no difference in the number of classes attended for male students earning grades above or below the class average (84 ± 3% vs. 79 ± 5%). Accordingly, some male students were absent frequently but scored above the class average, whereas other male students attended many classes but scored below the class average. Thus, the influence of regular attendance on examination performance is more important for female students than male students.
传统观点认为,成绩与出勤率有关,即出勤次数更多的学生成绩更好,出勤率显著有助于提高学习效果。然而,性别(女性与男性)对这种关系的影响研究较少。此外,已经有一些研究考察了出勤率对课程成绩的影响,这些研究挑战了传统观点。为了解决这些问题,我们确定了出勤率对参加我们本科运动生理学课程的 51 名学生(20 名女生和 31 名男生)考试成绩的影响。实验的设计不会干扰课程的正常进行。我们记录了每节课的出勤情况,虽然鼓励学生按时出勤,但并不要求学生必须出勤,而且出勤也不会影响最终成绩。最终成绩仅反映女生的平均出勤天数。具体来说,成绩高于班级平均分的女生平均出勤率为 89%±4%;然而,成绩低于班级平均分的女生平均出勤率仅为 64%±6%。相比之下,成绩高于或低于班级平均分的男生的出勤次数没有差异(84%±3%比 79%±5%)。因此,一些男生经常缺勤但成绩高于班级平均分,而另一些男生出勤次数多但成绩低于班级平均分。因此,出勤率对女生考试成绩的影响比男生更重要。