Nørgård Bente Mertz
Centre for National Clinical Databases, South, The Danish Clinical Quality Improvement Programme, OUH, Odense University Hospital, Entrance 101, Sdr. Boulevard 29, 5000 Odense C, Denmark.
Dan Med Bull. 2011 Dec;58(12):B4360.
The clinical epidemiological studies included in this thesis fall into three parts. The first part includes studies on birth outcome in women with ulcerative colitis. The second part includes pharmacoepidemiological studies on birth outcome after anti-inflammatory drug therapy in pregnancy, including patients with ulcerative colitis and Crohn's disease. The third part (and the latest publications) includes birth outcome in women with Crohn's disease; and the methods of cohort establishment in these studies are developed and improved due to the knowledge gathered from conducting the earlier studies. The birth outcomes in women with ulcerative colitis are examined in a nationwide, Danish, cohort of women based on data from the Danish National Hospital Discharge Registry and the Danish Medical Birth Registry, and within a Hungarian case-control data set. Our data suggest: 1) Significantly increased risk of preterm birth when women give birth 0-6 months after establishment of the diagnosis. It is considered whether the increased risk may be influenced by disease activity around the time of establishing the diagnosis. 2) No increased risk of giving birth to children with low birth weight, intrauterine growth retardation or congenital abnormalities (evaluated overall). 3) Significantly increased risk of some selected congenital abnormalities (limb deficiencies, obstructive urinary and multiple congenital abnormalities). No other studies have examined the risk of selected congenital abnormalities in children born by women with ulcerative colitis. The pharmacoepidemiological studies on birth outcomes after use of anti-inflammatory drug therapy in pregnancy, including women with ulcerative colitis and Crohn's disease, are based on data from the Hungarian case-control data set, a countywide Danish prescription Database, the Danish National Hospital Discharge Registry, the Danish Medical Birth Registry, and review of selected medical records. After exposure to sulfasalazine during pregnancy our data suggest. No significantly increased overall relative risk of congenital abnormalities and no significantly increased risks of selected congenital abnormalities. After exposure to 5-aminosalicylic acid during pregnancy our data suggest. No significantly increased relative risk of low birth weight, intrauterine growth retardation or congenital abnormalities (evaluated overall). A significantly increased relative risk of preterm birth and stillbirth in ulcerative colitis women, compared to women with no prescription of reimbursed medicine in pregnancy - and also after comparing with women with chronic inflammatory bowel disease not taking 5-aminosalicylic acid during pregnancy. It is not clear whether these associations are causal or influenced by confounding by disease activity in particular. After maternal exposure to azathioprine/6-mercaptopurine during pregnancy our data suggest. An increased relative risk of preterm birth, congenital abnormalities, and perinatal mortality - also after using controls with similar underlying diseases. It is difficult to rule out an influence of uncontrolled confounding. These were the first published data from a controlled observational study on exposed women with chronic inflammatory bowel disease. After preconceptional paternal use of azathioprine/6-mercaptopurine our data suggest An increased risk of congenital abnormalities, although not significantly increased. The birth outcomes in women with Crohn's disease are examined in nationwide sub-cohorts classified according to type of anti-inflammatory drug exposure during pregnancy, and based on data from the Danish National Hospital Discharge Registry, the nationwide Danish Prescription Database and the Danish Medical Birth Registry. Furthermore, birth outcomes are examined in Crohn's disease women with disease activity during pregnancy, based on data from review of hospital records, the Danish National Hospital Discharge Registry and the Danish Medical Birth Registry. Our data suggest: 1) The risk of adverse birth outcomes in women with Crohn's disease varies according to the type of anti-inflammatory drug therapy in pregnancy. 2) Reassuring results according to low birth weight, intrauterine growth retardation, preterm birth and congenital abnormalities after use of sulfasalazine/5-aminosalicylic acid or steroids. 3) Worrisome findings of a significantly increased risk of preterm birth and an increased risk of congenital abnormalities (not significantly increased) after prescription of azathioprine/6-mercaptopurine during pregnancy. Some residual confounding by disease activity may have been left in the analyses of preterm birth. In Crohn's disease women with disease activity during pregnancy our data suggest: 1) A significantly increased relative risk of preterm birth in women with the highest degree of disease activity during pregnancy. 2) Disease activity does not seem to increase the risk of low birth weight, intrauterine growth retardation or congenital abnormalities. This study is the first epidemiological study of the risk of adverse birth outcomes in Crohn's disease women with disease activity during pregnancy, compared to women with no activity during pregnancy, and in which confounders have been taken into consideration. Exceeding the studies included in my previous PhD thesis, this thesis provides new evidence on the following subjects: i) the risk of selected congenital abnormalities in children of women with ulcerative colitis, ii) pharmacoepidemiological studies on the risk of adverse birth outcome after maternal azathioprine/6-mercaptopurine exposure in pregnancy, and the risk of congenital abnormalities in children fathered by men treated with azathioprine/6-mercaptopurine before conception, iii) the risk of adverse birth outcome in women with Crohn's disease according to type of anti-inflammatory drug treatment in pregnancy (sulfasalazine/5-aminosalicylic acid, steroids or azathioprine/6-mercaptopurine), and iv) the impact of disease activity in women with Crohn's disease on adverse birth outcome. We learned from the studies in this thesis that the traditional way of reporting birth outcome in women with chronic inflammatory bowel disease, i.e. without having valid information on the type of underlying disease, concurrent therapeutic drug treatment and disease activity, is of limited value. The studies show that the risk of specific adverse birth outcome in women with ulcerative colitis and Crohn's disease depends on several factors including the time of birth in relation the début of disease, the type of underlying disease (ulcerative colitis or Crohn's disease), the type of anti-inflammatory drug treatment during pregnancy, and the degree of disease activity during pregnancy. At the same time one also has to realize that the existing evidence is still limited, especially in the field of reproductive safety after therapeutic drug treatment during pregnancy and possible effects of preconceptional therapeutic drug exposure.
本论文中的临床流行病学研究分为三个部分。第一部分包括对溃疡性结肠炎女性生育结局的研究。第二部分包括对孕期接受抗炎药物治疗后生育结局的药物流行病学研究,涵盖溃疡性结肠炎和克罗恩病患者。第三部分(也是最新的出版物)包括克罗恩病女性的生育结局;并且由于从早期研究中积累的知识,这些研究中的队列建立方法得到了发展和改进。基于丹麦国家医院出院登记处和丹麦医疗出生登记处的数据,以及匈牙利病例对照数据集,在丹麦全国范围内的女性队列中研究了溃疡性结肠炎女性的生育结局。我们的数据表明:1)在诊断确立后0 - 6个月分娩的女性,早产风险显著增加。考虑了这种增加的风险是否可能受到诊断确立时疾病活动的影响。2)出生低体重、宫内生长受限或先天性异常(总体评估)的风险没有增加。3)某些特定先天性异常(肢体缺陷、泌尿系统梗阻和多重先天性异常)的风险显著增加。没有其他研究考察过溃疡性结肠炎女性所生孩子特定先天性异常的风险。对孕期使用抗炎药物治疗后生育结局的药物流行病学研究,包括溃疡性结肠炎和克罗恩病女性,基于匈牙利病例对照数据集、丹麦一个县的处方数据库、丹麦国家医院出院登记处、丹麦医疗出生登记处的数据,以及对部分病历的审查。我们的数据表明,孕期暴露于柳氮磺胺吡啶后:先天性异常的总体相对风险没有显著增加,特定先天性异常的风险也没有显著增加。我们的数据表明,孕期暴露于5 - 氨基水杨酸后:出生低体重、宫内生长受限或先天性异常(总体评估)的相对风险没有显著增加。与孕期没有报销药物处方的女性相比,以及与孕期未服用5 - 氨基水杨酸的慢性炎症性肠病女性相比,溃疡性结肠炎女性早产和死产的相对风险显著增加。尚不清楚这些关联是因果关系还是特别受到疾病活动混杂因素的影响。我们的数据表明,孕期母亲暴露于硫唑嘌呤/6 - 巯基嘌呤后:早产、先天性异常和围产期死亡率的相对风险增加——在使用具有相似基础疾病的对照后也是如此。难以排除未控制的混杂因素的影响。这些是关于暴露于慢性炎症性肠病的女性的对照观察性研究的首批发表数据。我们的数据表明,孕前父亲使用硫唑嘌呤/6 - 巯基嘌呤后:先天性异常的风险增加,尽管没有显著增加。基于丹麦国家医院出院登记处、丹麦全国处方数据库和丹麦医疗出生登记处的数据,在全国范围内根据孕期抗炎药物暴露类型分类的亚队列中研究了克罗恩病女性的生育结局。此外,基于对医院记录、丹麦国家医院出院登记处和丹麦医疗出生登记处的审查数据,研究了孕期有疾病活动的克罗恩病女性的生育结局。我们的数据表明:1)克罗恩病女性不良生育结局的风险因孕期抗炎药物治疗类型而异。2)使用柳氮磺胺吡啶/5 - 氨基水杨酸或类固醇后,出生低体重、宫内生长受限、早产和先天性异常方面的结果令人安心。3)孕期使用硫唑嘌呤/6 - 巯基嘌呤后,早产风险显著增加且先天性异常风险增加(未显著增加),这一令人担忧的发现。在早产分析中可能仍存在一些疾病活动导致的残余混杂因素。对于孕期有疾病活动的克罗恩病女性,我们的数据表明:1)孕期疾病活动程度最高的女性早产的相对风险显著增加。2)疾病活动似乎不会增加出生低体重、宫内生长受限或先天性异常的风险。与孕期无疾病活动的女性相比,本研究是第一项关于孕期有疾病活动的克罗恩病女性不良生育结局风险的流行病学研究,并且考虑了混杂因素。与我之前博士论文中的研究相比,本论文在以下主题上提供了新的证据:i)溃疡性结肠炎女性所生孩子特定先天性异常的风险,ii)关于孕期母亲暴露于硫唑嘌呤/6 - 巯基嘌呤后不良生育结局风险以及孕前接受硫唑嘌呤/6 - 巯基嘌呤治疗的男性所生孩子先天性异常风险的药物流行病学研究,iii)根据孕期抗炎药物治疗类型(柳氮磺胺吡啶/5 - 氨基水杨酸、类固醇或硫唑嘌呤/6 - 巯基嘌呤),克罗恩病女性不良生育结局的风险,以及iv)克罗恩病女性疾病活动对不良生育结局的影响。我们从本论文的研究中了解到,传统的报告慢性炎症性肠病女性生育结局的方式,即没有关于基础疾病类型、同时进行的治疗药物治疗和疾病活动的有效信息,价值有限。研究表明,溃疡性结肠炎和克罗恩病女性特定不良生育结局的风险取决于几个因素,包括与疾病初发相关的分娩时间、基础疾病类型(溃疡性结肠炎或克罗恩病)、孕期抗炎药物治疗类型以及孕期疾病活动程度。同时,人们也必须认识到现有证据仍然有限,特别是在孕期治疗药物治疗后的生殖安全领域以及孕前治疗药物暴露的可能影响方面。