Psychology Program, Penn State University, Schuylkill Campus, PA 17972, USA.
J Interpers Violence. 2012 Jul;27(11):2276-97. doi: 10.1177/0886260511432143. Epub 2011 Dec 26.
The present study provides the first available evaluation of how violence with the mother and siblings during adulthood is associated with the occurrence of partner violence in young adults. Because a pattern of reciprocal partner violence is well documented, the authors hypothesized that reciprocal violence would also be found for adults and their mothers and for adults and their siblings. The authors also hypothesized that reciprocal violence with the mother and sisters would explain variance in partner violence even when controlling for other known predictors (poverty, poor family support, stress, anger, low self-esteem). Study participants included 377 college adults (114 men, 263 women; mean age = 24.4 years) who completed questionnaires to report their present violence to and from their mothers, sisters, brothers, and romantic partners. Violence is measured with a modified Conflict Tactics Scale. No sibling gender differences are found in violence reported as adults. Factor analysis confirms good fit for three clusters of reciprocal violence for adults: violence with the mother, violence with siblings, violence with the romantic partner. Violence with the mother and siblings significantly explains variance in partner violence even after controlling for other contextual variables, but only for women. One interpretation of present results is that because women receive less socialization than men to use violence, these two within-family models of violence have more significance for increasing their risk of partner violence. Partner violence prevention programs could include participation of mothers and siblings to enhance development of more peaceful conflict resolution patterns within and outside the family.
本研究首次评估了成年期与母亲和兄弟姐妹之间的暴力行为如何与青年期伴侣暴力的发生相关。由于互惠性伴侣暴力的模式已有充分记录,作者假设这种互惠性暴力也会在成年人与其母亲以及成年人与其兄弟姐妹之间存在。作者还假设,即使在控制了其他已知的预测因素(贫困、家庭支持差、压力、愤怒、自尊心低)后,与母亲和姐妹的互惠性暴力也会解释伴侣暴力的差异。研究参与者包括 377 名大学生(114 名男性,263 名女性;平均年龄=24.4 岁),他们完成了问卷,报告了他们目前与母亲、姐妹、兄弟和浪漫伴侣之间的暴力行为。暴力行为用改良的冲突策略量表进行衡量。在报告的成年人暴力行为中,没有发现兄弟姐妹之间的性别差异。因素分析证实了成年人之间三个互惠暴力集群的良好拟合:与母亲的暴力、与兄弟姐妹的暴力、与浪漫伴侣的暴力。即使在控制了其他情境变量后,与母亲和兄弟姐妹的暴力行为仍显著解释了伴侣暴力的差异,但仅对女性如此。目前结果的一种解释是,由于女性接受的使用暴力的社会化程度低于男性,因此这两种家庭内的暴力模式对增加她们遭受伴侣暴力的风险具有更大的意义。伴侣暴力预防计划可以包括母亲和兄弟姐妹的参与,以增强家庭内外更和平的冲突解决模式的发展。