Department of Paediatrics, Tuen Mun Hospital, Tuen Mun, Hong Kong.
Hong Kong Med J. 2012 Feb;18(1):25-9.
To investigate whether requests for standard paediatric electroencephalograms accord with guideline recommendations, subsequent changes in clinical management according to reported results, and extent to which the service meets waiting time targets.
Case series.
Regional hospital, Hong Kong.
All patients aged less than 18 years who underwent electroencephalography between December 2009 and February 2010.
Appropriateness of the electroencephalogram request and the impact of its findings on clinical management.
A total of 109 patients were recruited, but requests for standard electroencephalograms were considered 'inappropriate' with respect to guidelines in 44% of the patients, of which 50% were made to diagnose 'funny turns'. The standard electroencephalogram contributed to the diagnosis or management in only 28% of patients. In all of the latter, the request for an electroencephalogram had been appropriate. Nonspecialists made referrals for 86% of the patients. Inadequate information was provided in 66% of the requests. Standard electroencephalograms were performed within guideline targets, the wait being less than 4 weeks in 95% of requests.
An effective electroencephalogram service was being provided, though abuses were common. These were mainly because of misconceptions regarding the role and limitations of standard electroencephalograms. Through an educative, non-confrontational approach, and with time to explain guideline recommendations to clinicians, sustainable change in practice could be achieved so as to benefit patients, clinicians, and service provision.
调查儿科标准脑电图的申请是否符合指南建议,根据报告结果对临床管理的后续变化,以及服务满足等待时间目标的程度。
病例系列。
香港一家区域医院。
2009 年 12 月至 2010 年 2 月期间接受脑电图检查的所有年龄小于 18 岁的患者。
脑电图申请的适当性及其结果对临床管理的影响。
共纳入 109 例患者,但 44%的患者的脑电图申请被认为不符合指南,其中 50%是为了诊断“奇异转”。标准脑电图仅对 28%的患者的诊断或管理有贡献。在所有这些患者中,脑电图的申请都是恰当的。非专家为 86%的患者进行了转诊。66%的申请提供的信息不充分。标准脑电图的执行符合指南目标,95%的申请的等待时间小于 4 周。
尽管存在滥用现象,但提供了有效的脑电图服务。这些主要是由于对标准脑电图的作用和局限性存在误解。通过教育、非对抗性的方法,并为临床医生提供时间来解释指南建议,可以实现实践的可持续性改变,从而使患者、临床医生和服务提供者受益。