Department of Psychology, University of Saskatchewan, Canada.
Psychotherapy (Chic). 2010 Mar;47(1):134-9. doi: 10.1037/a0018838.
This case study is based upon data from a male patient with Avoidant Personality Disorder who was in psychoanalytic treatment for 5 years. Defense mechanism use was assessed by 3 coders using the Defense Mechanisms Rating Scales. Session transcripts from intake, each year of therapy, and 1-year follow-up were used for the ratings. Over the course of psychoanalysis and follow-up, the patient's Overall Defensive Functioning and High-Adaptive defense level use increased and his use of the Disavowal defense level and Fantasy decreased. The pattern of change throughout treatment was also assessed. The patient's Overall Defensive Functioning decreased initially, followed by an increase through year 4. Overall Defensive Functioning decreased again prior to termination before increasing to its highest level at follow-up. The results demonstrated changes consistent with hypotheses and theory, including overall improvement in defensive functioning, an initial regression of defensive functioning, decline in functioning immediately prior to termination, and continued improvement posttermination. This pattern of defense change highlights the importance of assessing defenses in treatment research.
本案例研究基于一位患有回避型人格障碍的男性患者的数据,他接受了 5 年的精神分析治疗。防御机制的使用由 3 名编码员使用防御机制评定量表进行评估。评定使用了摄入、每年治疗和 1 年随访的会话记录。在精神分析和随访过程中,患者的整体防御功能和高适应性防御水平的使用增加,而否认防御水平和幻想的使用减少。还评估了整个治疗过程中的变化模式。患者的整体防御功能最初下降,然后在第 4 年增加。在结束前再次下降,然后在随访中增加到最高水平。结果表明,变化与假设和理论一致,包括防御功能的整体改善、防御功能的初始倒退、结束前功能的下降以及结束后的持续改善。这种防御变化模式强调了在治疗研究中评估防御的重要性。