Prasad Soni, Lee Damian J, Yuan Judy Chia-Chun, Barao Valentim A R, Shyamsunder Nodesh, Sukotjo Cortino
Department of General Dental Sciences, Marquette University School of Dentistry, 1801 W Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, WI 53233-2186, USA.
Int J Dent. 2012;2012:859561. doi: 10.1155/2012/859561. Epub 2012 Feb 22.
Purpose. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the discrepancies between abstracts presented at the IADR meeting (2004-2005) and their full-text publication. Material and Methods. Abstracts from the Prosthodontic Section of IADR meeting were obtained. The following information was collected: abstract title, number of authors, study design, statistical analysis, outcome, and funding source. PubMed was used to identify the full-text publication of the abstracts. The discrepancies between the abstract and the full-text publication were examined, categorized as major and minor discrepancies, and quantified. The data were collected and analyzed using descriptive analysis. Frequency and percentage of major and minor discrepancies were calculated. Results. A total of 109 (95.6%) articles showed changes from their abstracts. Seventy-four (65.0%) and 105 (92.0%) publications had at least one major and one minor discrepancies, respectively. Minor discrepancies were more prevalent (92.0%) than major discrepancies (65.0%). The most common minor discrepancy was observed in the title (80.7%), and most common major discrepancies were seen in results (48.2%). Conclusion. Minor discrepancies were more prevalent than major discrepancies. The data presented in this study may be useful to establish a more comprehensive structured abstract requirement for future meetings.
目的。本研究的目的是评估在国际牙科研究协会会议(2004 - 2005年)上发表的摘要与其全文发表之间的差异。材料与方法。获取国际牙科研究协会会议口腔修复科的摘要。收集以下信息:摘要标题、作者数量、研究设计、统计分析、结果和资金来源。使用PubMed识别摘要的全文发表。检查摘要与全文发表之间的差异,分为主要差异和次要差异并进行量化。使用描述性分析收集和分析数据。计算主要差异和次要差异的频率和百分比。结果。共有109篇文章(95.6%)与其摘要有所变化。分别有74篇(65.0%)和105篇(92.0%)出版物至少存在一处主要差异和一处次要差异。次要差异(92.0%)比主要差异(65.0%)更为普遍。最常见的次要差异出现在标题中(80.7%),最常见的主要差异出现在结果中(48.2%)。结论。次要差异比主要差异更为普遍。本研究中呈现的数据可能有助于为未来会议建立更全面的结构化摘要要求。