Baumann R P, Moore G W
Department of Pathology, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore.
Schweiz Med Wochenschr. 1990 Dec 8;120(49):1876-9.
We are reporting the first results of a comparative study of 100 consecutive autopsies and their clinical diagnoses, observed at the Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions (JHMI) and at the Institut neuchâtelois d'anatomie pathologique (INAP). The diagnoses of the two series were coded according to the two different systems used currently at the two institutions. The data from Baltimore were automatically classified by a special "key word method" using the categories of the Index Medicus (MeSH = Medical subject headings). We proceeded then to a second recording by SNOMED codes, introduced into the computer system in the same way as we document the autopsy diagnoses in Neuchâtel. The two series could be compared in detail according to topographical, morphological and aetiological parameters. The over-all repartition of the examined cases shows a higher incidence of newborns in Baltimore (23), in Neuchâtel we observed only 7 newborn autopsies. The mean age was inferior in Baltimore (males: 53.5 years for JHMI, 73.1 years for INAP; females: 58.4 years for JHMI, 66.2 years for INAP). The number of diagnoses per autopsy was 31.9 at JHMI, and 50.1 in Neuchâtel. The topographical distribution of clinical and autopsy diagnoses showed a higher frequency of central nervous system lesions in JHMI which might be explained by the activity of a neuropathological division. Findings concerning the morphological categories revealed a higher frequency in JHMI for traumatic abnormalities (7.2% vs 2.5%), malformations (4.3% vs 0.8%), whereas inflammation and fibrosis and degenerative lesions were more often encountered in Neuchâtel. The differences in morphological observations could be attributed to a higher proportion of newborn cases in JHMI with complex malformation syndromes.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
我们报告了在约翰霍普金斯医疗机构(JHMI)和纳沙泰尔病理解剖研究所(INAP)对100例连续尸检及其临床诊断进行比较研究的首批结果。两个系列的诊断依据两所机构目前使用的两种不同系统进行编码。来自巴尔的摩的数据通过一种特殊的“关键词法”,依据《医学索引》(MeSH = 医学主题词)的类别自动分类。然后我们用SNOMED编码进行第二次记录,其录入计算机系统的方式与我们在纳沙泰尔记录尸检诊断的方式相同。两个系列可以根据解剖位置、形态学和病因学参数进行详细比较。所检查病例的总体分布显示,巴尔的摩新生儿的发病率更高(23例),在纳沙泰尔我们仅观察到7例新生儿尸检。巴尔的摩的平均年龄更低(男性:JHMI为53.5岁,INAP为73.1岁;女性:JHMI为58.4岁,INAP为66.2岁)。JHMI每例尸检的诊断数为31.9个,纳沙泰尔为50.1个。临床和尸检诊断的解剖位置分布显示,JHMI中枢神经系统病变的频率更高,这可能是由一个神经病理学部门的活动所致。关于形态学类别的发现显示,JHMI创伤性异常的频率更高(7.2%对2.5%)、畸形(4.3%对0.8%),而炎症、纤维化和退行性病变在纳沙泰尔更常出现。形态学观察的差异可归因于JHMI中患有复杂畸形综合征的新生儿病例比例更高。(摘要截选至250词)