Luchins Daniel
Department of Psychiatry, University of Illinois at Chicago, and Mental Health Research, Jesse Brown Veteran Affairs Medical Center, Chicago, 60612, USA.
Perspect Biol Med. 2012;55(2):283-90. doi: 10.1353/pbm.2012.0023.
This article questions the view that medical decision-making can be reduced to a series of explicit rules, adherence to which will necessarily improve outcomes. Instead, it attempts to rehabilitate the concepts of clinical expertise and clinical experience, arguing that medicine, like other areas of expertise, depends on forms of implicit knowledge that can only be acquired through years of experience. Recent research on "fast and frugal" heuristics in medical decision-making suggest that statistical techniques are not necessarily superior to clinician judgment. Since clinical decisions are made on individual patients within the constraint of limited information, they must rest on clinical expertise and not clinical rules.
医学决策可简化为一系列明确的规则,遵循这些规则必然会改善治疗结果。相反,它试图恢复临床专业知识和临床经验的概念,认为医学与其他专业领域一样,依赖于只能通过多年经验获得的隐性知识形式。近期关于医学决策中“快速且节俭”启发法的研究表明,统计技术不一定优于临床医生的判断。由于临床决策是在有限信息的约束下针对个体患者做出的,所以这些决策必须基于临床专业知识而非临床规则。