Department of Mental Health, Naval Medical Center, San Diego, CA, USA.
CNS Spectr. 2012 Mar;17(1):11-5. doi: 10.1017/S1092852912000016.
Risk for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) varies in part due to the nature of the traumatic event involved. Both injury and return from combat pose high risk of PTSD symptoms. How different injuries may predispose towards PTSD is less well understood.
A retrospective record review was conducted from 1402 service members who had returned to Naval Medical Center San Diego from Iraq or Afghanistan and who had completed the PTSD Checklist as part of their post-deployment screening. Rates of PTSD were examined in relation to mechanism of injury.
Of those without injury, 8% met Diagnostic and Statistical Manual criteria for PTSD. Thirteen percent of those with a penetrating injury, 29% with blunt trauma, and 33% with combination injuries met criteria for PTSD. PTSD severity scores varied significantly according to type of injury.
The World War I concept of "shell shock" implied that blast-related injuries were more likely to result in psychological symptoms than were other injuries. These data may support that idea. Circumstance of injury, population differences, and reporting bias could also have influenced the results.
These results suggest that service members with blunt or combination injuries merit particular attention when screening for PTSD.
创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的风险部分取决于所涉及的创伤事件的性质。受伤和从战斗中归来都会导致 PTSD 症状的高风险。不同的伤害如何导致 PTSD 还不太清楚。
对从伊拉克或阿富汗返回圣地亚哥海军医疗中心的 1402 名海军陆战队员进行了回顾性病历审查,他们在部署后筛查中完成了 PTSD 检查表。根据损伤机制检查 PTSD 的发生率。
在没有受伤的人群中,有 8%符合 PTSD 诊断和统计手册标准。有 13%的穿透性损伤、29%的钝性创伤和 33%的混合性损伤符合 PTSD 标准。根据损伤类型,PTSD 严重程度评分差异显著。
第一次世界大战中的“炮弹休克”概念暗示爆炸相关损伤比其他损伤更有可能导致心理症状。这些数据可能支持这一观点。受伤的情况、人群差异和报告偏差也可能影响结果。
这些结果表明,在筛选 PTSD 时,应特别关注有钝性或混合性损伤的军人。