Department of Sociology, Columbia University, MC 9649, New York, NY 10027, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2012 Nov;75(9):1633-41. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2012.06.023. Epub 2012 Jul 21.
How can genetics reshape nosology? This paper examines the way knowledge about a genetic mutation - the microdeletion at chromosomal locus 22q11.2 - transformed our understanding of several rare clinical syndromes and designated a qualitatively new population of patients. Taking the 1400 papers about the 22q11.2 deletion and the clinical conditions with which it was associated, we generate a network of papers tied by citations for each of the last 35 years. Using a modularity algorithm, we identify communities and evaluate their salience for the networks' overall structure. This analysis, supplemented by historical research and fieldwork with relevant experts and the advocates of affected children conducted during 2011-12, reveals that the 22q11.2 deletion acted as a 'boundary object' that unified clinical literatures and led to the emergence of a new kind of medical condition: 22q11.2 Deletion Syndrome (DS). The case of 22q11.2DS extends our understanding of 'genomic designation' - the delineation and diagnosis of clinically diffuse conditions according to characteristics of the genome - and demonstrates that observations from genetics can reconfigure existing categories of biomedical research and lead to the emergence of qualitatively new diagnostic categories.
遗传学如何重塑疾病分类学?本文考察了对一种基因突变(染色体 22q11.2 微缺失)的认识如何改变了我们对几种罕见临床综合征的理解,并确定了一类新的患者。我们对过去 35 年来与 22q11.2 缺失及其相关临床病症相关的 1400 篇论文进行了分析,使用模块性算法识别了各网络论文间的联系,并评估了它们对整个网络结构的重要性。通过补充历史研究和对相关专家以及受影响儿童的倡导者进行的实地考察,我们发现 22q11.2 缺失充当了一个“边界物体”,将临床文献统一起来,导致了一种新的医疗条件的出现:22q11.2 缺失综合征(22q11.2DS)。22q11.2DS 的案例扩展了我们对“基因组指定”的理解,即根据基因组的特征来描绘和诊断广泛存在的病症,并表明遗传学的观察结果可以重新配置现有的生物医学研究类别,并导致出现定性上的新诊断类别。