Department of Emergency Medicine, Madigan Army Medical Center, Tacoma, WA 98431, USA.
Clin Toxicol (Phila). 2012 Sep;50(8):764-9. doi: 10.3109/15563650.2012.716159. Epub 2012 Aug 17.
We conducted a prospective randomized controlled study on the influence of multiple doses of activated charcoal (MDAC) in patients with supratherapeutic serum phenytoin levels;
Patients with serum phenytoin levels greater than 30 mg/L upon presentation to the ED were recruited from two urban teaching hospitals. Patients enrolled were older than 18, nonpregnant, able to tolerate activated charcoal by mouth and able to give written consent. They were randomized to receive 50 g activated charcoal by mouth every 4 hours or no activated charcoal. They continued in the study until the patient was discharged or the serum level was <25 mg/L. Serum levels were drawn every 6 hours initially, then every 24 hours after the 1st day. The presence of gait abnormalities and nystagmus was recorded and mini-mental status exam (MMSE) scores were collected from each patient enrolled. Time to reach subtoxic levels was recorded;
Seventeen patients were enrolled in the study. Seven patients received MDAC, eight patients served as controls and two patients who were initially enrolled as controls inadvertently received one dose of activated charcoal and were excluded from the analysis. Both groups were comparable in age and all were male. The median time to reach a subtoxic level was 41.1 hours (range, 11.6-196) and 19.3 hours (range, 13-33) in the control and charcoal groups, respectively (p = 0.049). The median and range peak serum levels were 40.0 hours (range, 32.0-47.6) and 35.6 hours (range, 32.5-40.0) in the control and charcoal groups, respectively (p = 0.082). The median and range MMSE scores were 20 points (range, 12-30) and 19.5 points (range, 16-29) in the control and charcoal groups, respectively;
Further study is needed to determine if MDAC decreases the time to reach a subtoxic level of phenytoin in patients with supratherapeutic phenytoin levels.
我们进行了一项前瞻性随机对照研究,探讨多次剂量活性炭(MDAC)对超治疗血清苯妥英水平患者的影响;
从两家城市教学医院招募了就诊时血清苯妥英水平大于 30 mg/L 的患者。纳入的患者年龄大于 18 岁,非妊娠,能够口服活性炭,并且能够书面同意。他们被随机分为每 4 小时口服 50 g 活性炭或不给予活性炭。他们继续在研究中,直到患者出院或血清水平<25 mg/L。最初每 6 小时抽取血清水平,然后第 1 天后每 24 小时抽取一次。记录步态异常和眼球震颤的存在,并从每位纳入的患者收集简易精神状态检查(MMSE)评分。记录达到亚毒性水平的时间;
17 名患者入组本研究。7 名患者接受 MDAC,8 名患者作为对照组,2 名最初作为对照组入组的患者无意中接受了一剂活性炭,被排除在分析之外。两组在年龄上具有可比性,且均为男性。达到亚毒性水平的中位时间分别为 41.1 小时(范围,11.6-196)和 19.3 小时(范围,13-33),在对照组和活性炭组中(p=0.049)。对照组和活性炭组的中位和范围峰值血清水平分别为 40.0 小时(范围,32.0-47.6)和 35.6 小时(范围,32.5-40.0)(p=0.082)。对照组和活性炭组的 MMSE 评分中位数和范围分别为 20 分(范围,12-30)和 19.5 分(范围,16-29);
需要进一步研究以确定多次剂量活性炭是否可以缩短超治疗苯妥英水平患者达到亚毒性水平的时间。