San Francisco VA Medical Center and University of California, San Francisco, CA 94121, USA.
J Affect Disord. 2013 Mar 5;145(3):344-8. doi: 10.1016/j.jad.2012.08.021. Epub 2012 Sep 7.
Our goal was to better understand distinct PTSD symptom presentations in Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans (N=227) and to determine whether those who killed in war were at risk for being in the most symptomatic class.
We used latent class analysis of responses to the PTSD checklist and logistic regression of most symptomatic class.
We found that a four-class solution best fit the data, with the following profiles emerging: High Symptom (34% of participants), Intermediate Symptom (41%), Intermediate Symptom with Low Emotional Numbing (10%), and Low Symptom (15%). The largest group of individuals who reported killing (45%) was in the High Symptom class, and those who killed had twice the odds of being in the most symptomatic PTSD class, compared to those who did not kill. Those who endorsed killing a non-combatant (OR=4.56, 95% CI [1.77, 11.7], p<0.01) or killing in the context of anger or revenge (OR=4.63, 95% CI=[1.89, 11.4], p<0.001) were more likely to belong to the most symptomatic PTSD class, compared to those who did not kill.
The study was retrospective and cross-sectional. The results may not generalize to veterans of other wars.
Killing in war may be an important indicator of risk for developing frequent and severe PTSD symptoms. This has implications for the mental healthcare of veterans, providing evidence that a comprehensive evaluation of returning veterans should include an assessment of killing experiences and reactions to killing.
我们的目标是更好地了解伊拉克和阿富汗退伍军人(N=227)中不同的 PTSD 症状表现,并确定在战争中杀人的人是否有处于最典型症状类别的风险。
我们使用 PTSD 检查表的潜在类别分析和最典型症状类别的逻辑回归。
我们发现,四分类方案最适合数据,出现以下特征:高症状(34%的参与者)、中症状(41%)、中症状伴低情绪麻木(10%)和低症状(15%)。报告杀人的人数最多的一组(45%)在高症状类别中,与未杀人者相比,杀人者有两倍的机会处于最典型的 PTSD 类别。那些表示杀害非战斗人员(OR=4.56,95%CI[1.77,11.7],p<0.01)或在愤怒或复仇背景下杀人(OR=4.63,95%CI=[1.89,11.4],p<0.001)的人更有可能属于 PTSD 症状最典型的类别。
该研究是回顾性和横断面的。结果可能不适用于其他战争的退伍军人。
在战争中杀人可能是频繁和严重 PTSD 症状发生的重要指标。这对退伍军人的心理健康护理具有重要意义,为返回的退伍军人的全面评估应包括对杀人经历和对杀人的反应的评估提供了证据。