Human Sensorimotor Control Laboratory, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
Exp Brain Res. 2012 Nov;223(1):137-47. doi: 10.1007/s00221-012-3247-9. Epub 2012 Sep 12.
Humans routinely estimate the size and weight of objects. Yet, when lifting two objects of equal weight but different size, they often perceive the smaller object as being heavier. This size-weight illusion (SWI) is known to have a lesser effect on motor control of object lifting. How the nervous system combines "weight" and "size" cues with prior experience and whether these cues are differentially integrated for perception and sensorimotor action is still not fully understood. Therefore, we assessed not only whether the experience of size biases weight perception, but also if experience of weight biases the size perception of objects. Further, to investigate differences between perceptual and motor systems for cue-experience integration, participants haptically explored the weight of an object with one hand and then shaped the aperture of their other hand to indicate its perceived size. Results-First, next to a SWI, healthy adults (N = 21) perceived lighter objects as being smaller and heavier objects as being larger, demonstrating a weight-size illusion (WSI). Second, participants were more susceptible to either the SWI or WSI. Third, aperture of the non-exploring hand was scaled to perceived weight and not to physical size. Hand openings were consistently smaller than physical size, with SWI-sensitive participants being significantly more affected than WSI-sensitive subjects. We conclude: first, both size and weight perceptions are biased by prior experience. Weight perception is biased by expectations of size, while size perception is influenced by the expectancy of weight. Second, humans have the tendency to use one cue predominantly for both types of perception. Third, combining perceived weight with expected size influenced hand motor control, while online haptic feedback was largely ignored. Finally, we present a processing model underlying the size-weight cue integration for the perceptual and motor system.
人类经常会估计物体的大小和重量。然而,当提起两个重量相同但大小不同的物体时,他们通常会认为较小的物体更重。这种大小-重量错觉(SWI)对物体提起的运动控制的影响较小。神经系统如何将“重量”和“大小”线索与先前的经验结合起来,以及这些线索是否对感知和运动感觉动作有不同的整合,目前还不完全清楚。因此,我们不仅评估了大小经验是否会影响对重量的感知,还评估了重量经验是否会影响对物体大小的感知。此外,为了研究感知和运动系统对线索经验整合的差异,参与者用一只手触觉探索物体的重量,然后用另一只手塑造开口来指示其感知到的大小。结果——首先,除了 SWI 之外,健康成年人(N=21)还将较轻的物体感知为较小,将较重的物体感知为较大,从而产生了重量-大小错觉(WSI)。其次,参与者更容易受到 SWI 或 WSI 的影响。第三,非探索手的开口大小与感知到的重量成正比,而与物理尺寸不成比例。手开口始终小于物理尺寸,SWI 敏感的参与者受影响明显大于 WSI 敏感的参与者。我们得出结论:首先,大小和重量感知都受到先前经验的影响。重量感知受到对大小的期望的影响,而大小感知受到对重量的期望的影响。其次,人类倾向于主要使用一种线索来进行这两种感知。第三,将感知到的重量与预期的大小相结合会影响手部运动控制,而在线触觉反馈则在很大程度上被忽略。最后,我们提出了一个感知和运动系统的大小-重量线索整合的处理模型。