Lu Bo, Hoogerheide David P, Zhao Qing, Yu Dapeng
State Key Laboratory for Mesoscopic Physics and Electron Microscopy Laboratory, School of Physics, Peking University, Beijing 100871, People's Republic of China.
Phys Rev E Stat Nonlin Soft Matter Phys. 2012 Jul;86(1 Pt 1):011921. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevE.86.011921. Epub 2012 Jul 23.
A detailed understanding of the origin of the electrophoretic force on DNA molecules in a solid-state nanopore is important for the development of nanopore-based sequencing technologies. Because of the discrepancies between recent attempts to predict this force and both direct and indirect experimental measurements, this topic has been the focus of much recent discussion. We show that the force is predictable to very good accuracy if all of the experimental conditions are accounted for properly. To resolve this issue, we compare the calculation efficiency and accuracy of numerical solutions of Poisson-Boltzmann and Poisson-Nernst-Planck descriptions of electrolyte behavior in the nanopore in the presence of DNA molecules. Two geometries--axially symmetric and cross-sectional--are compared and shown to be compatible. Numerical solutions are carried out on a sufficiently fine mesh to evaluate the viscous drag force acting on DNA inside a silicon nitride nanopore. By assuming the DNA is immobilized in the axial center of the nanopore, the calculation result of this viscous drag force is found to be rather larger than the experimental result. Because the viscous drag force decreases if DNA is closer to the surface of the nanopore, however, the relevant effective driving force is the average over all possible positions of the DNA in the nanopore. When this positional uncertainty is taken into account, the effective driving force acting on DNA inside the nanopore is found to agree very well with the experimental results.
深入了解固态纳米孔中DNA分子电泳力的起源对于基于纳米孔的测序技术的发展至关重要。由于近期预测这种力的尝试与直接和间接实验测量结果之间存在差异,该主题成为了近期诸多讨论的焦点。我们表明,如果能恰当地考虑所有实验条件,该力是可以非常精确地预测的。为解决这个问题,我们比较了在存在DNA分子的情况下,纳米孔中电解质行为的泊松 - 玻尔兹曼描述和泊松 - 能斯特 - 普朗克描述的数值解的计算效率和准确性。比较了两种几何形状——轴对称和横截面——并表明它们是兼容的。在足够精细的网格上进行数值解,以评估作用在氮化硅纳米孔内DNA上的粘性阻力。通过假设DNA固定在纳米孔的轴向中心,发现这种粘性阻力的计算结果比实验结果大得多。然而,由于如果DNA更靠近纳米孔表面粘性阻力会减小,所以相关的有效驱动力是DNA在纳米孔中所有可能位置上的平均值。当考虑到这种位置不确定性时,发现作用在纳米孔内DNA上的有效驱动力与实验结果非常吻合。