Department of Health and Applied Social Sciences, University of the West of England, Bristol, United Kingdom.
Med Anthropol. 2013;32(1):61-74. doi: 10.1080/01459740.2012.692741.
In the arena of biomedical sciences, technical skills and expert judgment are at a premium, and the standardization and repeatability of an intervention is crucial to help determine, for example, the effectiveness of a new drug in a clinical trial. Crystal and spiritual healers are less rule-bound, and their playfulness with the systematized conventions and rituals of healing practice is more evident. In this article, based on in-depth ethnographic research, I highlight some of these themes in the context of contemporary crystal and spiritual healing practice at a center in northeast England. I show that the standardized models of measuring effectiveness are less appropriate in many healing contexts, partly due to the unrepeatability and limited standardization of each healing performance, but also due to the performative 'being-in-the-moment-ness' and intuitive sensibility that frames what healers count as evidence.
在生物医学科学领域,专业技能和专家判断至关重要,干预措施的标准化和可重复性对于确定临床试验中新药物的疗效等至关重要。水晶和精神治疗师的规则约束较少,他们对治疗实践的系统化规范和仪式的嬉戏更为明显。在本文中,我基于深入的民族志研究,在英格兰东北部的一个中心的当代水晶和精神治疗实践背景下强调了其中的一些主题。我表明,在许多治疗环境中,衡量有效性的标准化模型不太适用,部分原因是每次治疗效果的不可重复性和有限的标准化,也部分是因为治疗师认为证据的表现性“当下存在”和直观敏感性。