Department of Physical Therapy, Mount Sinai Hospital, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2013 Apr;94(4):650-9. doi: 10.1016/j.apmr.2012.12.003. Epub 2012 Dec 13.
To compare the effects of ultraviolet-C (UVC) with placebo-UVC on pressure ulcer healing in individuals with spinal cord injury (SCI).
Double-blind randomized trial with stratification for ulcer location to buttock or lower extremity. Subjects were followed up for 1 year postintervention.
Rehabilitation institution.
Adult inpatients and outpatients (N=43) with SCI and stage 2 to 4 pressure ulcers (n=58).
Ulcers and periwound skin were irradiated 3 times per week using UVC or placebo-UVC. The endpoint was wound closure or hospital discharge without closure.
Primary outcome was weekly percent area relative to baseline. Secondary outcomes were mean percent area change between consecutive weeks, surface appearance, weeks to closure, and impact on quality of life and wound status postintervention.
Groups were similar at baseline for all demographic characteristics except ulcer duration (P=.02). Groups were similar when healing was compared overall. Subgroup analysis showed that the percent area relative to baseline for stage 2 buttock ulcers was significantly smaller in the group receiving UVC compared with placebo at weeks 3, 5, and 7. During weeks 1 through 8, these ulcers were 26% to 76% of baseline area using UVC versus 111% to 180% for placebo (achieved significant level [ASL], .03-.08; effect size, 0.5-0.8). Groups were similar in the percent area relative to baseline for stage 2 lower extremity ulcers. Group mean percent area change between consecutive weeks for all stage 2 ulcers was 36.6% with the use of UVC and 5.8% for placebo (ASL=.09). There were no group differences in the percent area relative to baseline and the mean percent area change between consecutive weeks for stage 3 to 4 ulcers. Groups were similar for all other secondary outcomes.
UVC is beneficial for stage 2 buttock ulcers. Further studies are warranted using a larger sample size, carefully considered exclusion criteria, and strategies to ensure homogeneity of the groups that are being compared.
比较紫外线-C(UVC)与安慰剂-UVC 对脊髓损伤(SCI)个体压疮愈合的影响。
分层为臀部或下肢溃疡的双盲随机试验。受试者在干预后 1 年进行随访。
康复机构。
成人住院和门诊患者(N=43),患有 SCI 和 2 至 4 期压疮(n=58)。
每周 3 次使用 UVC 或安慰剂-UVC 对溃疡和周围皮肤进行照射。终点是伤口闭合或无闭合出院。
主要结果是每周相对于基线的面积百分比。次要结果是连续数周平均面积变化百分比、表面外观、愈合所需的周数以及干预后对生活质量和伤口状况的影响。
除溃疡持续时间外(P=.02),所有人口统计学特征在基线时两组相似。整体愈合情况两组相似。亚组分析显示,与安慰剂相比,接受 UVC 治疗的 2 期臀部溃疡相对于基线的面积百分比在第 3、5 和 7 周时显著较小。在第 1 周到第 8 周期间,这些溃疡的面积分别为基线面积的 26%至 76%,而安慰剂组的面积为 111%至 180%(达到显著水平[ASL],.03-.08;效应量,0.5-0.8)。2 期下肢溃疡两组的基线面积相对百分比相似。所有 2 期溃疡连续数周的组平均面积变化百分比为 UVC 组的 36.6%,安慰剂组的 5.8%(ASL=.09)。3 至 4 期溃疡的基线面积和连续数周的平均面积变化百分比,两组间无差异。两组在所有其他次要结果方面相似。
UVC 对 2 期臀部溃疡有益。需要进行更大样本量、仔细考虑排除标准以及确保正在比较的组同质的策略的进一步研究。