Nikita Efthymia
Leverhulme Centre for Human Evolutionary Studies, University of Cambridge, Fitzwilliam Street, Cambridge, CB2 1QH, U.K.
J Forensic Sci. 2013 Mar;58(2):324-9. doi: 10.1111/1556-4029.12047. Epub 2012 Dec 27.
Intercostal and age differences in the sternal rib end morphology of documented female skeletons from Spitalfields and St. Bride's are examined. The morphology was captured using three-dimensional morphometrics and the statistical analyses employed included parametric and nonparametric MANOVA, discriminant analysis, and multilinear regressions. It was found that the quantified morphology of the sternal rib end was statistically significantly different between rib four and all other ribs except for the third one and that the morphological characteristics of all ribs varied with age. However, due to the inherent variability in sternal rib end morphology, nonstatistically significant results were obtained among the various age groups and neither disciminant nor multilinear regression analysis could be used for the estimation of the age of an individual based on digitized coordinates of the sternal rib end of individuals of known age, raising some concern as to the rigorousness of the fourth rib aging method.
对来自斯皮塔菲尔德和圣布里德的有记录的女性骨骼胸骨肋端形态的肋间差异和年龄差异进行了研究。使用三维形态计量学获取形态,并采用了包括参数和非参数多变量方差分析、判别分析和多线性回归在内的统计分析方法。结果发现,除第三肋外,第四肋与所有其他肋骨的胸骨肋端量化形态在统计学上有显著差异,并且所有肋骨的形态特征随年龄变化。然而,由于胸骨肋端形态存在固有变异性,在不同年龄组之间获得了无统计学意义的结果,并且判别分析和多线性回归分析均不能用于根据已知年龄个体的胸骨肋端数字化坐标来估计个体年龄,这引发了对第四肋年龄判定方法严谨性的一些担忧。