Khan Aamer Zaman
Department of General Surgery, Fatima Jinnah Medical College, Lahore, Pakistan.
J Coll Physicians Surg Pak. 2013 Jan;23(1):5-9.
To identify the non-academic attributes developed during 5 years of training in medical school.
Sequential mixed method.
The study was conducted on final year medical students of four medical colleges in the city of Lahore, from March to September 2010.
Probability random sampling was employed to identify public sector medical colleges for inclusion in the study through Lottery method. In the first phase, survey was done with the help of questionnaires, distributed amongst 280 students, selected on the basis of convenience sampling. It was triangulated with data collected by in-depth structured interviews on 46 students selected using purposive sampling after formal informed consent. For quantitative data percentages of the categorical variables were calculated through SPSS version 10. For qualitative data, themes and patterns were identified using Content Analysis technique.
Majority of the medical students (80%) learn the attributes of integrity, self-reliance, tolerance and independence during their schooling. Sixty five percent students thought that the values of humanity, forbearance, righteous attitude in face of adversities and sympathetic behaviour towards peers and patients helped them in being better medical students. Thirty five percent said they faced the negative influences of gender bias and gender discrimination which has led to their impaired professional growth. Eighty percent of the students believe that the teaching methodology employed is teacher centric which does not let them become problem solvers, team players, reflective learners and hampers development of effective communication skills.
Medical schooling in our part of the world helps in developing untaught attributes such as integrity, selfreliance, tolerance, independence, sympathetic attitude and good communication skills which are the same as are developed in the medical students of advanced countries, which can be fostered further by formally addressing them in the curriculum.
确定医学院校5年学习期间培养的非学术性特质。
序贯混合法。
2010年3月至9月,在拉合尔市四所医学院的最后一年医学生中开展研究。
采用概率随机抽样,通过抽签法确定纳入研究的公立部门医学院校。第一阶段,借助问卷进行调查,问卷分发给280名基于便利抽样选取的学生。在正式获得知情同意后,对采用立意抽样选取的46名学生进行深入结构化访谈,并收集数据进行三角互证。对于定量数据,通过SPSS 10版计算分类变量的百分比。对于定性数据,采用内容分析法确定主题和模式。
大多数医学生(80%)在求学期间培养了正直、自立、宽容和独立的特质。65%的学生认为人性、忍耐、面对逆境时的正确态度以及对同伴和患者的同情行为有助于他们成为更好的医学生。35%的学生表示他们面临性别偏见和性别歧视的负面影响,这导致他们职业发展受损。80%的学生认为所采用的教学方法以教师为中心,这使他们无法成为问题解决者、团队合作者和反思性学习者,也阻碍了有效沟通技能的发展。
在我们这个地区,医学院校教育有助于培养正直、自立、宽容、独立、同情态度和良好沟通技能等未被教授的特质,这些特质与发达国家医学生所培养的特质相同,可通过在课程中正式提及进一步加以培养。