Loring David W, Bowden Stephen C
a Departments of Neurology and Pediatrics , Emory University School of Medicine , Atlanta , GA , USA .
Clin Neuropsychol. 2014;28(4):556-74. doi: 10.1080/13854046.2012.762552. Epub 2013 Jan 29.
Reporting appropriate research detail across clinical disciplines is often inconsistent or incomplete. Insufficient report detail reduces confidence in findings, makes study replication more difficult, and decreases the precision of data available for critical review including meta-analysis. In response to these concerns, cooperative attempts across multiple specialties have developed explicit research reporting standards to guide publication detail. These recommendations have been widely adopted by high impact medical journals, but have not yet been widely embraced by neuropsychology. The STROBE Statement (STrengthening the Reporting of Observational studies in Epidemiology) is particularly relevant to neuropsychology since clinical research is often based on non-funded studies of patient samples. In this paper we describe the STROBE Statement and demonstrate how STROBE criteria, applied to reporting of neuropsychological findings, will maintain neuropsychology's position as a leader in quantifying brain-behavior relationships. We also provide specific recommendations for data reporting and disclosure of perceived conflicts of interest that will further enhance reporting transparency for possible perceived sources of bias. In an era in which evidence-based practice assumes an increasingly prominent role, improved reporting standards will promote better patient care, assist in developing quality practice guidelines, and ensure that neuropsychology remains a vigorous discipline in the clinical neurosciences that consciously aspires to high methodological rigor.
跨临床学科报告适当的研究细节往往不一致或不完整。报告细节不足会降低对研究结果的信心,使研究复制更加困难,并降低可用于包括荟萃分析在内的批判性审查的数据精度。针对这些问题,多个专业领域的合作努力制定了明确的研究报告标准,以指导出版细节。这些建议已被高影响力的医学期刊广泛采用,但尚未被神经心理学广泛接受。《加强流行病学观察性研究报告声明》(STROBE声明)与神经心理学特别相关,因为临床研究通常基于对患者样本的非资助研究。在本文中,我们描述了STROBE声明,并展示了将STROBE标准应用于神经心理学研究结果报告将如何保持神经心理学在量化脑-行为关系方面的领先地位。我们还提供了关于数据报告和披露潜在利益冲突的具体建议,这将进一步提高报告透明度,以应对可能存在的偏见来源。在循证实践日益重要的时代,改进报告标准将促进更好的患者护理,有助于制定高质量的实践指南,并确保神经心理学在临床神经科学中仍然是一个充满活力的学科,自觉追求高度的方法严谨性。