Li Zhi, Wang Xin-zhi, Gao Cheng-zhi, Ivo Krejci
Department of Prosthodontics, Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology, Beijing,China.
Beijing Da Xue Xue Bao Yi Xue Ban. 2013 Feb 18;45(1):59-63.
To evaluate the fatigue and fracture resistance of the flared roots restored with computer aided design (CAD) and computer aided manufacturing (CAM) glass fiber posts.
In the study, 32 maxillary central incisors with roots longer than 13 mm were selected and their canals were flared, and the roots were allocated into 4 groups (n=8) by a random number chart: CAD/CAM glass fiber posts, prefabricated quartz fiber posts, cast gold alloy posts, and CAD/CAM zirconia posts. The posts were luted to the roots by resin cement and fabricate zirconia crown for every specimen. An addition-type silicone impression material was used to simulate the periodontal ligament. All the specimens were submitted to 1.2×10(6) cycles loaded with a 49 N force, at 45 degree to the long axis of the teeth simultaneously with 3 000 thermal cycles (5 °C-50 °C-5 °C). After that, the specimens were subjected to a load at a crosshead speed of 1 mm/min in a servo-hydraulic testing machine applied at 45 degree to the long axis of the tooth until fracture. The data were subjected to ANOVA test and the patterns of the failure were examined.
After the cycling loading, 4 crowns from prefabricated quartz fiber posts groups were deboned, and no other failure was found after the cycling loading; the fracture strengths of CAD/CAM glass fiber posts group [(441.5± 103.2) N] and cast gold alloy posts group [(462.9±170.0) N] were higher (F=4.613, P<0.05) than those of CAD/CAM zirconia posts group [(284.1±99.0) N] and prefabricated quartz fiber posts group [(315.4±112.3) N]; the entire specimens presented unfavorable failures.
Although further in vitro and in vivo studies are necessary, the results of this study show that the use of CAD/CAM glass fiber posts and cast gold alloy posts may achieve better outcomes in flared roots than that of CAD/CAM zirconia posts and prefabricated quartz fiber posts.
评估采用计算机辅助设计(CAD)和计算机辅助制造(CAM)玻璃纤维桩修复的扩大型牙根的抗疲劳性和抗折性。
本研究选取32颗牙根长度超过13mm的上颌中切牙,对其根管进行扩大型处理,然后通过随机数字表将牙根分为4组(n = 8):CAD/CAM玻璃纤维桩组、预成石英纤维桩组、铸造金合金桩组和CAD/CAM氧化锆桩组。用树脂水门汀将桩粘结到牙根上,并为每个样本制作氧化锆全冠。采用加成型硅橡胶印模材料模拟牙周膜。所有样本同时承受1.2×10⁶次循环加载,加载力为49N,加载角度与牙长轴呈45度,同时进行3000次热循环(5℃ - 50℃ - 5℃)。之后,在伺服液压试验机上以1mm/min的十字头速度对样本施加与牙长轴呈45度的载荷直至折断。对数据进行方差分析并检查失败模式。
循环加载后,预成石英纤维桩组有4个全冠脱粘,循环加载后未发现其他失败情况;CAD/CAM玻璃纤维桩组[(441.5±103.2)N]和铸造金合金桩组[(462.9±170.0)N]的抗折强度高于CAD/CAM氧化锆桩组[(284.1±99.0)N]和预成石英纤维桩组[(315.4±112.3)N](F = 4.613,P < 0.05);所有样本均呈现不良失败情况。
尽管有必要进行进一步的体外和体内研究,但本研究结果表明,在扩大型牙根中,使用CAD/CAM玻璃纤维桩和铸造金合金桩可能比CAD/CAM氧化锆桩和预成石英纤维桩取得更好的效果。