Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Nagoya University School of Medicine, 65 Tsurumai Showa-ward, Nagoya, Aichi 466-8550, Japan.
Eur Spine J. 2013 Aug;22(8):1891-6. doi: 10.1007/s00586-013-2722-8. Epub 2013 Apr 4.
The purpose of this study is to analyze the data in terms of the number of channels employed to examine the usefulness of multi-channels in intraoperative spinal cord monitoring.
The prerequisites for inclusion in the baseline data were as follows: (1) cases in which only CMAP monitoring was conducted; (2) cases in which monitoring was conducted under the same stimulation condition and the recording condition. Cases where inhalation anesthesia was used or muscle relaxants were used as maintenance anesthesia was excluded from the baseline data. Of the 6,887 cases, 884 cases met the criteria. The items examined for each of the different numbers of channels were the sensitivity and specificity, the false positive rate, the false negative rate, and the coverage rate of postoperative motor deficit muscles.
To examine these two items in terms of the number of channels, the 4-channel group had lower sensitivity and specificity scores compared with the 8- and 16-channel groups (4 channels 73/93 %, 8 channels 100/97 %, 16 channels 100/95 %). Only four channels were derived for these cases and the coverage of postoperative motor deficit muscles was 38 % with only 30 out of the 80 postoperative motor deficit muscles in total being monitored. In the 8-channel group, it was 60 % with 12 of the 20 postoperative motor deficit muscles being monitored. The 16-channel group had 100 % coverage rate of postoperative motor deficit muscles.
We suggest that multi-channel monitoring of at least eight channels is desirable for intraoperative spinal cord monitoring.
本研究旨在分析使用通道数量的数据,以检验多通道在术中脊髓监测中的有效性。
纳入基线数据的前提条件如下:(1)仅进行 CMAP 监测的病例;(2)在相同刺激条件和记录条件下进行监测的病例。排除使用吸入麻醉或肌肉松弛剂作为维持麻醉的病例。在 6887 例病例中,884 例符合标准。对不同通道数量检查的项目包括敏感性和特异性、假阳性率、假阴性率以及术后运动缺陷肌肉的覆盖率。
为了根据通道数量检查这两个项目,4 通道组的敏感性和特异性评分低于 8 通道和 16 通道组(4 通道 73/93%,8 通道 100/97%,16 通道 100/95%)。这些病例只得出了四个通道,术后运动缺陷肌肉的覆盖率为 38%,总共 80 个术后运动缺陷肌肉中只有 30 个得到监测。在 8 通道组中,监测到 20 个术后运动缺陷肌肉中的 12 个,覆盖率为 60%。16 通道组对术后运动缺陷肌肉的覆盖率为 100%。
我们建议术中脊髓监测至少需要 8 个通道的多通道监测。