Zhu Feng, Sun Xu, Qiao Jun, Ding Yitao, Zhang Bing, Qiu Yong
Departments of *Spine Surgery †Surgery ‡Radiology, the Affiliated Drum Tower Hospital of Nanjing University Medical School, Nanjing, China.
J Spinal Disord Tech. 2014 Dec;27(8):431-5. doi: 10.1097/BSD.0b013e31828d6a1b.
A retrospective study.
To assess the accuracy and safety of the placement of pedicle screws (PSs) on pediatric patients with congenital scoliosis younger than 10 years through postoperative computed tomography scanning.
The accuracy of the placement of PSs in adolescent and adult population with various spinal problems has been thoroughly studied. As to pediatric patients with congenital scoliosis, the related studies were inadequate.
A retrospective review was carried out on 96 pediatric patients with congenital scoliosis younger than 10 years, who received posterior instrumentation from February 2006 to June 2012. Postoperative computed tomography scan was utilized to assess the accuracy of PS placement. Pedicle perforations were classified as medial, lateral, or anterior and categorized into 1 of the 4 grades: grade 1, ≤2 mm; grade 2, 2.1-4.0 mm; grade 3, 4.1-6.0 mm; and grade 4, ≥6.1 mm. The positions of screws were also classified as acceptable (fully contained screws or with screws either ≤2 mm of medial wall perforation or ≤6 mm of lateral wall perforation and without impingement of visceral organs) or unacceptable. The variables of PS position as defined by fully contained were statistically examined using the Fisher (2-tailed) exact test with regard to: (1) side of the curvature (convex or concave); (2) region (thoracic or lumbar); (3) magnitude of the curvature (<80 or ≥80 degrees); (4) apical region and overall; (5) deformed vertebrae versus normal vertebrae.
A total of 625 screws were inserted; 512 screws (81.9%) were fully contained within the cortical boundaries of the pedicle. Five hundred and sixty-nine (91.0%) screws were regarded as acceptably positioned, whereas 56 (9.0%) as unacceptably positioned. Among the 625 screws inserted, 317 were inserted in the thoracic spine, of which 67 (21.1%) led to perforations, and 308 screws were inserted in the lumbar spine, of which 46 (14.9%) led to perforations. The breach rate was found to be higher in thoracic spine than in the lumbar spine (P<0.05). Of the 625 screws inserted, 306 screws were inserted on the concave side of the curve, of which 50 (16.3%) led to perforations, and 319 were inserted on the convex side, of which 63 (19.7%) led to perforations. There is no difference with regard to the breach rates between the concave side and the convex side of the curve (P>0.05). Of the 625 screws, 328 were inserted in patients with a Cobb angle <80 degrees, of which 41 (12.5%) screws perforated the pedicles, and 297 screws were inserted in the patients with a Cobb angle >80 degrees, of which 72 (24.2%) screws perforated the pedicles. The breach rate was higher in the patients with the Cobb angle >80 degrees than in the patients with the Cobb angle <80 degrees (P<0.05). One hundred and fifty-four screws were inserted in the apical vertebrae, of which 57 (37.1%) screws perforated the pedicle walls. The breach rate in apical vertebrae was higher than the overall (55/154 vs. 113/625) (P<0.05). Among the 625 screws, 252 screws were inserted in the deformed vertebrae, of which 58 (23.0%) perforated the pedicle walls, and 373 screws were inserted in the normal vertebrae, of which 55 (14.7%) perforated the pedicle walls. The breach rate in the deformed vertebrae was higher than the normal vertebrae (P<0.05).
PSs insertion in pediatric patients with congenital scoliosis was less accurate than that in adult patients. However, the safety of placement was quite satisfactory. The possibility of pedicle breaching increased when placing PSs at deformed vertebra, on the apex of the curve, and in the thoracic spine, which reminds surgeons to be more cautious when placing PSs in these regions.
一项回顾性研究。
通过术后计算机断层扫描评估10岁以下先天性脊柱侧凸患儿椎弓根螺钉(PSs)置入的准确性和安全性。
PSs在患有各种脊柱问题的青少年和成人中的置入准确性已得到充分研究。对于先天性脊柱侧凸的儿科患者,相关研究不足。
对96例10岁以下先天性脊柱侧凸患儿进行回顾性研究,这些患儿在2006年2月至2012年6月期间接受了后路内固定。利用术后计算机断层扫描评估PS置入的准确性。椎弓根穿孔分为内侧、外侧或前方,并分为4个等级中的1个:1级,≤2mm;2级,2.1 - 4.0mm;3级,4.1 - 6.0mm;4级,≥6.1mm。螺钉位置也分为可接受(完全包含在椎弓根皮质边界内或螺钉内侧壁穿孔≤2mm或外侧壁穿孔≤6mm且无内脏器官受压)或不可接受。对于完全包含定义的PS位置变量,使用Fisher(双侧)精确检验对以下方面进行统计学检验:(1)弯曲侧(凸侧或凹侧);(2)区域(胸椎或腰椎);(3)弯曲度数(<80或≥80度);(4)顶椎区域及总体;(5)畸形椎体与正常椎体。
共置入625枚螺钉;512枚螺钉(81.9%)完全包含在椎弓根皮质边界内。569枚(91.0%)螺钉位置可接受,而56枚(9.0%)不可接受。在置入的625枚螺钉中,317枚置入胸椎,其中67枚(21.1%)导致穿孔,308枚置入腰椎,其中46枚(14.9%)导致穿孔。发现胸椎的穿孔率高于腰椎(P<0.05)。在置入的625枚螺钉中,306枚置入弯曲凹侧,其中50枚(16.3%)导致穿孔,319枚置入凸侧,其中63枚(19.7%)导致穿孔。弯曲凹侧和凸侧的穿孔率无差异(P>0.05)。在625枚螺钉中,328枚置入Cobb角<80度的患者,其中41枚(12.5%)螺钉穿破椎弓根,297枚螺钉置入Cobb角>80度的患者,其中72枚(24.2%)螺钉穿破椎弓根。Cobb角>80度患者的穿孔率高于Cobb角<80度患者(P<0.05)。154枚螺钉置入顶椎,其中57枚(37.1%)螺钉穿破椎弓根壁。顶椎的穿孔率高于总体(55/154对113/625)(P<0.05)。在625枚螺钉中,252枚置入畸形椎体,其中58枚(23.0%)穿破椎弓根壁,373枚置入正常椎体,其中55枚(14.7%)穿破椎弓根壁。畸形椎体的穿孔率高于正常椎体(P<0.05)。
先天性脊柱侧凸患儿PSs置入的准确性低于成人患者。然而,置入的安全性相当令人满意。在畸形椎体、弯曲顶点和胸椎置入PSs时椎弓根穿破的可能性增加,这提醒外科医生在这些区域置入PSs时要更加谨慎。