Konovalov A N, Kozlov A V, Cherekaev V A, Shimansiĭ V N, Taniashin S V, Kornienko V N, Pronin I N, Golanov A V, Kobiakov G L, Shishkina L V, Ryzhova M V, Gol'bin D A, Galkin M V, Bocharov A A, Lasunin N V
Zh Vopr Neirokhir Im N N Burdenko. 2013;77(1):12-23.
The paper describes the history of meningioma surgery at Burdenko Neurosurgical Institute, analyses of accumulated series of patients and assesses effectiveness of different techniques for meningioma diagnosis and treatment of. We analyzed 15413 patients with meningiomas operated in Burdenko Neurosurgical Institute from 1932 to 2011. Mathematical analysis was performed using Statistica 6.0 program. Mortality rate during World War II reached a disastrous level of 45,8%, in 21st century it is below 1%. Temporary and permanent morbidity has also decreased. While in 1961 Karnofsky performance score was 71, in 2011 it became 83. The probability of postoperative tumour recurrence also diminished, from 40% in 1960-s to 29% in 1996 and presumably to 25% nowadays. Independent factors that influence the risk of recurrence are primary gross total resection, grade of anaplasia and radiation therapy. However, unreasonably aggressive surgery leads to significant increase of morbidity. Further improvement of surgical results in patients with meningiomas depends on implementation of new technologies for neurovisualization, abandoning extensive surgical approaches whenever possible, finding the "balance" between radical removal and expected functional outcome, wider application of radiosurgery and three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy.
本文描述了布尔坚科神经外科研究所脑膜瘤手术的历史,分析了积累的患者系列,并评估了脑膜瘤诊断和治疗的不同技术的有效性。我们分析了1932年至2011年在布尔坚科神经外科研究所接受手术的15413例脑膜瘤患者。使用Statistica 6.0程序进行数学分析。第二次世界大战期间死亡率达到灾难性的45.8%,在21世纪则低于1%。临时和永久性发病率也有所下降。1961年卡诺夫斯基功能状态评分是71,2011年变为83。术后肿瘤复发的概率也降低了,从20世纪60年代的40%降至1996年的29%,目前可能降至25%。影响复发风险的独立因素是初次肉眼全切、间变程度和放射治疗。然而,不合理的激进手术会导致发病率显著增加。脑膜瘤患者手术结果的进一步改善取决于实施神经可视化新技术,尽可能放弃广泛的手术方法,在根治性切除和预期功能结果之间找到“平衡”,更广泛地应用放射外科和三维适形放射治疗。