Center for Resources, Environment and Food Security, China Agricultural University, Beijing 100193, China.
Environ Sci Technol. 2013 Jun 4;47(11):6015-22. doi: 10.1021/es4003026. Epub 2013 May 23.
Although both the grain yields and environmental costs of nitrogen (N) fertilization are gaining more public and scientific debate, the complex linkages among crop productivity, N application rate, environmental footprints, and the consequences of improved N management are not well understood. We considered the concept of linking greenhouse gas (GHG) emission, reactive N losses, and N fertilizer application rates with crop productivity to determine the response of the GHG emission and reactive N losses to N surplus and further evaluated the potential to reduce these N environmental footprints by in-season root-zone N management. A meta-analysis suggested an exponential increase in the response of direct N2O emissions and nitrate leaching to an increasing N surplus, while NH3 volatilization increased linearly with an increasing N application rate for intensive wheat production in north China. The GHG emission and reactive N losses during N fertilizer application increased exponentially with an increasing N surplus. By pooling all 121 on-farm experimental sites, an in-season root-zone N management strategy was shown to reduce the N application rate by 61% from 325 kg N ha(-1) to 128 kg N ha(-1) compared to the farmers' N practice, with no loss in wheat grain yield. As a result, the intensity of GHG emission and reactive N losses were reduced by 77% and 80%, respectively. The intensity of GHG emission and reactive N losses can be further reduced due to the improved N recovery and increased grain yield achieved by best crop management. In conclusion, N recovery efficiency and yield improvements should be used to reduce future agricultural N environmental footprints, rather than reducing the N application rate.
尽管氮肥(N)施肥的粮食产量和环境成本越来越受到公众和科学界的关注,但作物生产力、N 施用量、环境足迹以及改善 N 管理的后果之间的复杂联系仍未得到很好的理解。我们考虑将温室气体(GHG)排放、活性 N 损失和 N 施肥率与作物生产力联系起来的概念,以确定 GHG 排放和活性 N 损失对 N 盈余的响应,并进一步评估通过季内根区 N 管理减少这些 N 环境足迹的潜力。一项荟萃分析表明,直接 N2O 排放和硝酸盐淋失对 N 盈余的响应呈指数增长,而在中国北方集约小麦生产中,NH3 挥发则随 N 施用量的增加呈线性增加。N 施肥期间的 GHG 排放和活性 N 损失随 N 盈余的增加呈指数增长。通过汇集所有 121 个田间试验点,与农民的 N 实践相比,季内根区 N 管理策略显示可将 N 施用量从 325 kg N ha(-1)减少到 128 kg N ha(-1),减少 61%,而小麦籽粒产量没有损失。因此,GHG 排放和活性 N 损失的强度分别降低了 77%和 80%。通过最佳作物管理提高 N 回收率和增加籽粒产量,可以进一步降低 GHG 排放和活性 N 损失的强度。总之,应利用 N 回收率和产量的提高来减少未来农业的 N 环境足迹,而不是减少 N 施用量。