Health Promotion Research Center, Zahedan University of Medical Sciences, Zahedan, Iran.
J Voice. 2013 Sep;27(5):655.e17-21. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2013.03.003. Epub 2013 May 15.
In Iran, the total number of elementary schoolteachers is estimated to be nearly 300 000 people and this population is at risk for developing voice disorders. Acoustical characteristics of voice for schoolteachers in Iran are unknown but are relevant to the quantitative description, diagnosis, intervention, reassessment, and outcomes of their voices.
Fifteen female and 15 male Iranian primary schoolteachers in the age range of 35-40 years with 15 years teaching experience volunteered to participate in the study. The control group consisted of 30 Iranian adults aged 35-40 years (15 men and 15 women). Recordings and audio signal analyses were carried out using Praat software. Each subject was asked to sustain the vowel /â/ using habitual and constant vocal pitch, loudness, and quality for at least 5 seconds. Five tokens from each subject were obtained.
For the male subjects, the results indicated no significant difference (at the 0.05 level) for each variable between the two groups. However, for the female subjects, t tests showed significant differences between the teachers and the nonteacher controls in all parameters at the 0.01 level. The Iranian female teachers had significantly lower F(0) (190.27 Hz) than the control group (236.32 Hz). Also, for the perturbation acoustic parameters (jitter% and shimmer%), the female teacher group had significantly higher values than their corresponding control group. Similarly, the harmonics-to-noise ratio (HNR) measures for the Iranian female teacher population were significantly lower than for their corresponding control group.
The results indicate that female Iranian teachers appear to be more susceptible to voice stability change than the male Iranian teachers. Also, acoustic analysis of voice for teachers may significantly contribute to the objective voice examination of this group. Further investigations of factors that promote individual susceptibility to vocal stability are necessary.
在伊朗,小学教师总数估计接近 30 万人,这一人群存在发生嗓音障碍的风险。伊朗学校教师的嗓音声学特征尚不清楚,但与嗓音的定量描述、诊断、干预、再评估和结果有关。
15 名 35-40 岁、教龄 15 年的伊朗小学女教师和 15 名男教师自愿参加了这项研究。对照组由 30 名 35-40 岁的伊朗成年人(15 男 15 女)组成。使用 Praat 软件进行录音和音频信号分析。要求每位受试者用习惯性和恒定的音高、响度和音质至少持续发出/v/音 5 秒。从每位受试者获得 5 个样本。
对于男性受试者,结果表明两组之间在每个变量上均无显著差异(0.05 水平)。然而,对于女性受试者,t 检验显示,在 0.01 水平上,教师组与非教师对照组在所有参数上均有显著差异。伊朗女教师的 F0(190.27 Hz)显著低于对照组(236.32 Hz)。此外,在扰动力声学参数(jitter%和 shimmer%)方面,女教师组的数值显著高于对照组。同样,伊朗女教师群体的谐噪比(HNR)测量值也显著低于对照组。
结果表明,与伊朗男教师相比,伊朗女教师似乎更容易发生嗓音稳定性变化。此外,对教师嗓音的声学分析可能会显著促进对该人群的客观嗓音检查。有必要进一步研究促进个体对嗓音稳定性易感性的因素。