Centre for Forensic Science, The University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Crawley, Australia.
Forensic Sci Int. 2013 Sep 10;231(1-3):402.e1-6. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2013.05.029. Epub 2013 Jun 24.
An important component of forensic investigation is the identification of deceased (and increasingly living) individuals, which is often the role of the forensic anthropologist. One of the most valuable steps towards identification is via a biological profile, developed through the application of population specific standards. In disaster victim identification scenarios, fleshed feet are often recovered in footwear; footprints are another potential source of trace evidence found at crime scenes. In medico-legal investigations, feet and footprints can be useful for extrapolating living height, it is thus expedient to determine whether sex can be estimated from the same anthropometric data. The aim of the present study is to develop accurate sex estimation standards for a contemporary Western Australian population from measurements of the feet and footprints. The sample comprises 200 adults (90 males, 110 females). Three bilateral linear measurements were taken from each foot and seven bilateral measurements were acquired from static footprints obtained using a Podograph. A precision test was first conducted to assess data accuracy and reliability. Measurement data are then analysed using a range of parametric statistical tests. Results show that males were significantly (P<0.001) larger than females for all foot and footprint measurements; cross-validated sex classification accuracies ranged from 71% to 91%. Although in many instances the sex bias was large (>±5%), this study provides viable alternatives for estimating sex in Western Australian individuals with accuracy equivalent to established standards developed from foot bones.
法医调查的一个重要组成部分是识别死者(和越来越多的生者),这通常是法医人类学家的角色。识别的最重要步骤之一是通过生物特征进行识别,这是通过应用特定人群的标准来实现的。在灾难受害者识别场景中,通常会在鞋中发现有肉的脚;脚印是犯罪现场发现的另一种潜在的痕迹证据来源。在法医学调查中,脚和脚印可以用于推断活体身高,因此确定是否可以从相同的人体测量数据中估计性别是很方便的。本研究的目的是从脚和脚印的测量中为当代西澳大利亚人口制定准确的性别估计标准。该样本包括 200 名成年人(90 名男性,110 名女性)。从每只脚采集了三个双侧线性测量值,并从使用 Podograph 获得的静态脚印中采集了七个双侧测量值。首先进行了精度测试,以评估数据的准确性和可靠性。然后使用一系列参数统计检验来分析测量数据。结果表明,对于所有脚和脚印测量值,男性均显著大于女性(P<0.001);交叉验证的性别分类准确率在 71%至 91%之间。尽管在许多情况下性别偏差很大(>±5%),但本研究为在西澳大利亚个体中估计性别提供了可行的替代方案,其准确性与从脚骨中开发的既定标准相当。