Department of General Practice and Health Services Research, University Hospital Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany.
Ann Fam Med. 2013 Jul-Aug;11(4):363-70. doi: 10.1370/afm.1498.
Hospitalizations for ambulatory care-sensitive conditions (ACSCs) are seen as potentially avoidable with optimal primary care. Little is known, however, about how primary care physicians rate these hospitalizations and whether and how they could be avoided. This study explores the complex causality of such hospitalizations from the perspective of primary care physicians.
We conducted semistructured interviews with 12 primary care physicians from 10 primary care clinics in Germany regarding 104 hospitalizations of 81 patients with ACSCs at high risk of rehospitalization.
Participating physicians rated 43 (41%) of the 104 hospitalizations to be potentially avoidable. During the interviews the cause of hospitalization fell into 5 principal categories: system related (eg, unavailability of ambulatory services), physician related (eg, suboptimal monitoring), medical (eg, medication side effects), patient related (eg, delayed help-seeking), and social (eg, lack of social support). Subcategories frequently associated with physicians' rating of hospitalizations for ACSCs as potentially avoidable were after-hours absence of the treating physician, failure to use ambulatory services, suboptimal monitoring, patients' fearfulness, cultural background and insufficient language skills of patients, medication errors, medication nonadherence, and overprotective caregivers. Comorbidities and medical emergencies were frequent causes attributed to ACSC-based hospitalizations that were rated as being unavoidable.
Primary care physicians rated a significant proportion of hospitalizations for ACSCs to be potentially avoidable. Strategies to avoid these hospitalizations may target after-hours care, optimal use of ambulatory services, intensified monitoring of high-risk patients, and initiatives to improve patients' willingness and ability to seek timely help, as well as patients' medication adherence.
从初级保健的角度来看,门诊保健敏感型疾病(ACSCs)的住院治疗被认为是可以避免的,如果提供最佳的初级保健,这些住院治疗可能会减少。然而,人们对初级保健医生如何评估这些住院治疗以及这些住院治疗是否可以避免知之甚少。本研究从初级保健医生的角度探讨了这些住院治疗的复杂因果关系。
我们对德国 10 家初级保健诊所的 12 名初级保健医生进行了半结构化访谈,探讨了 81 名 ACSC 高再住院风险患者的 104 例住院治疗案例。
参与研究的医生认为 104 例住院中有 43 例(41%)是可以避免的。在访谈过程中,住院的原因可以分为 5 个主要类别:系统相关(例如,门诊服务不可用)、医生相关(例如,监测不佳)、医疗相关(例如,药物副作用)、患者相关(例如,寻求帮助延迟)和社会相关(例如,缺乏社会支持)。与医生评估 ACSC 住院治疗可避免性相关的亚类经常是主治医生不在岗、未使用门诊服务、监测不佳、患者恐惧、患者文化背景和语言技能不足、用药错误、用药不依从以及过度保护的护理人员。合并症和医疗紧急情况是 ACSC 相关住院治疗的常见原因,被认为是不可避免的。
初级保健医生认为 ACSC 住院治疗中有相当一部分是可以避免的。避免这些住院治疗的策略可能针对夜间护理、最佳利用门诊服务、加强对高危患者的监测以及提高患者及时寻求帮助的意愿和能力,以及提高患者的用药依从性。