Davies Andrew P
Morriston Hospital, Swansea, SA6 6NL, United Kingdom.
Knee. 2013 Dec;20(6):482-4. doi: 10.1016/j.knee.2013.07.005. Epub 2013 Aug 15.
Unicompartmental patellofemoral arthroplasties are uncommon however numbers are increasing and there are a variety of new prostheses available. The Femoro-Patella Vialla (FPV, Wright Medical) device was the second most commonly used patellofemoral unicompartmental prosthesis in the 2012 British National Joint Register. There are however no published outcomes data for this device.
52 consecutive cases were studied prospectively using Oxford Knee Score and American Knee Society Scores pre-operatively and at follow up to a minimum of two years.
Overall Oxford Knee Scores improved from 30 points pre-operatively (36.6%) to 19 points (60%) at one-year. American Knee Society Knee scores improved from 51 points pre-operatively to 81 points at one-year. Function scores improved from 42 points pre-operatively to 70 points at one-year. 13 (25%) patients had an excellent outcome with pain abolished and near normal knee function. 11 (21%) patients gained very little improvement and scored their knees similar or worse to their pre-operative state. There were no infective or thromboembolic complications. Seven cases have been revised to a total knee replacement for on-going pain in six cases and progression of arthritis in the tibio-femoral compartments in one case. The patellar button was found to be very poorly fixed in all cases that were revised.
Early results with the FPV prosthesis demonstrate that successful outcomes can be achieved however the results were unpredictable and a significant minority of patients had on-going symptoms that they found unacceptable. The early revision rate was high in this series.
单髁髌股关节置换术并不常见,但数量正在增加,并且有多种新型假体可供使用。股骨-髌骨维亚拉(FPV,赖特医疗公司)装置是2012年英国国家关节注册中心第二常用的髌股单髁假体。然而,尚无关于该装置的已发表疗效数据。
前瞻性研究了52例连续病例,术前及随访至少两年时使用牛津膝关节评分和美国膝关节协会评分。
牛津膝关节评分总体上从术前的30分(36.6%)提高到一年时的19分(60%)。美国膝关节协会膝关节评分从术前的51分提高到一年时的81分。功能评分从术前的42分提高到一年时的70分。13例(25%)患者获得了极佳的疗效,疼痛消失且膝关节功能接近正常。11例(21%)患者改善甚微,膝关节评分与术前相似或更差。未发生感染或血栓栓塞并发症。7例因持续疼痛(6例)和胫股关节间关节炎进展(1例)而翻修为全膝关节置换术。在所有翻修病例中,均发现髌骨纽扣固定非常差。
FPV假体的早期结果表明可以取得成功的疗效,但结果不可预测,并且有相当一部分患者存在他们认为无法接受的持续症状。本系列的早期翻修率很高。