Wilbrand J F, Hagemes F, Wilbrand M, Kühnemann J, Dey F, Streckbein P, Howaldt H P
Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 2014 Nov;51(6):632-8. doi: 10.1597/13-010. Epub 2013 Sep 4.
Objective : To photogrammetrically objectify changes in nonsynostotic craniofacial deformity in orthotically treated versus untreated infants. Design : A statistical retrospective pairwise comparison of two respective three-dimensional (3D) photo scans of 80 children performed in a 6-month time lag. Patients : Two comparable samples of children (40 treated, 40 untreated) with nonsynostotic cranial deformity. Interventions : Respective 3D photo scans were matched using Cranioform Analytics 4.0 software. Main Outcome Measures : Median change of 30° Cranial Vault Asymmetry Index (CVAI), modified CVAI (CVAImod), Cranial Index (CI), and posterior symmetry ratio (PSR). Results : We found an improvement in Δ30° CVAI by 3.3% (treated) and by 1.31% (untreated), respectively. CVAImod improved by 3.46% in the treated group and by 1.55% in the untreated group. CI improved by 4.41% in the treated group and by 3.68% in the untreated group, and PSR improved by 0.71 in the treated group and 0.49 in the untreated group. Although improvement of cranial asymmetry was higher in those children treated with an individual molding orthosis, we could not document a statistically significant difference between the two groups. Conclusions : Helmet therapy may be less appropriate for the correction of brachycephaly than for cranial asymmetry. Nonsynostotic cranial deformity shows some spontaneous correction. Photogrammetry presents an accurate method to objectify craniofacial changes in early infancy.
通过摄影测量法客观评估接受矫形治疗与未接受治疗的婴儿非骨性融合性颅面畸形的变化。设计:对80名儿童在6个月时间间隔内进行的两次三维(3D)照片扫描进行统计学回顾性配对比较。患者:两组具有可比性的非骨性融合性颅骨畸形儿童样本(40名接受治疗,40名未接受治疗)。干预措施:使用Cranioform Analytics 4.0软件对各自的3D照片扫描进行匹配。主要观察指标:30°颅穹不对称指数(CVAI)、改良CVAI(CVAImod)、颅指数(CI)和后对称率(PSR)的中位数变化。结果:我们发现,治疗组和未治疗组的Δ30° CVAI分别改善了3.3%和1.31%。治疗组的CVAImod改善了3.46%,未治疗组改善了1.55%。治疗组的CI改善了4.41%,未治疗组改善了3.68%,治疗组的PSR改善了0.71,未治疗组改善了0.49。尽管使用个性化塑形矫形器治疗的儿童颅骨不对称改善程度更高,但我们未能证明两组之间存在统计学上的显著差异。结论:头盔疗法对于矫正扁头畸形可能不如矫正颅骨不对称合适。非骨性融合性颅骨畸形有一定的自发矫正。摄影测量法是一种客观评估婴儿早期颅面变化的准确方法。