Dr. McGovern is senior program officer, Burroughs Wellcome Fund, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina. Ms. Kramarik is senior program associate, Burroughs Wellcome Fund, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina. Mr. Wilkins is research technician, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, North Carolina.
Acad Med. 2013 Nov;88(11):1732-9. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0b013e3182a83172.
Documenting the career characteristics of a highly selective group of researchers provides some insight into how a successful career begins. This knowledge is of value to early-career faculty and those who evaluate them, as well as trainees who aspire to the professoriate and those who educate them.
In 2010, the authors extracted information by hand from the curricula vitae of 196 basic scientists who have been supported by the Burroughs Wellcome Fund's early faculty career development programs from 1982 to 2010. Data were collected on awardees' education, awards and honors, funding, promotion, publication, service, and training activities. The end point for data was December 2010. Analyses quantified participants' time to terminal degree, faculty appointment, and first R01; determined their publication productivity; and calculated their rates of training graduate students and postdoctoral fellows.
This group moved into jobs and gained first R01s faster than average. Surprisingly, those who train the most students and fellows do not publish the most. Women and men trained different numbers of undergraduates, PhDs, and postdocs. Women awardees had fewer publications on average than men.
Researchers who are highly competitive at the early faculty career stage have generally been both timely in their arrival at important benchmarks and productive in terms of their scientific output. Newly trained researchers and the people and institutions that train them share responsibility for attaining expeditious progress, developing a substantial track record, and staking out fertile intellectual ground from which to grow an independent faculty career.
记录高度选择性研究人员群体的职业特征,有助于深入了解成功职业的开端。这方面的知识对于处于早期职业阶段的教师以及对他们进行评估的人员、有志于教授职位的学员以及对他们进行教育的人员都具有重要价值。
2010 年,作者通过手工从 196 位基础科学家的简历中提取信息,这些科学家在 1982 年至 2010 年期间获得了 Burroughs Wellcome 基金的早期教职职业发展计划的支持。数据收集的内容包括获奖者的教育背景、奖项和荣誉、资助、晋升、发表文章、服务和培训活动。数据的截止日期为 2010 年 12 月。分析计算了参与者获得最终学位、教职任命和第一个 R01 的时间;确定了他们的发表文章生产力;并计算了培训研究生和博士后的比例。
这组人员进入工作岗位并获得第一个 R01 的速度快于平均水平。令人惊讶的是,培训学生和博士后人数最多的人并不是发表文章最多的人。女性和男性培训的本科生、博士和博士后数量不同。女性获奖者的平均出版物数量少于男性。
在早期教职职业阶段极具竞争力的研究人员在到达重要里程碑的时间和他们的科学产出方面通常都很及时和高效。新培训的研究人员以及培训他们的人和机构都有责任迅速取得进展、建立实质性的记录,并为独立教职职业打下肥沃的智力基础。