Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Beaumont Health System, Royal Oak, MI.
Phys Sportsmed. 2013 Sep;41(3):77-84. doi: 10.3810/psm.2013.09.2026.
Interscalene nerve blocks (ISBs) have been shown to be an effective option for regional anesthesia in shoulder surgery. Our study presents survey results of shoulder surgeons' perceptions of ISBs and a literature summary of complications rates with ISB use.
A survey addressing demographics, preferences, treatment patterns, risks/benefits, and patient recommendations regarding the use of ISBs was created. Respondents were also asked whether they would elect an ISB if personally undergoing shoulder surgery, and results of other questions were stratified based on this personal preference. The survey was administered electronically to all members of the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons. A literature review of ISB-related complication rates was compiled from 13 studies of shoulder surgery using ISB.
Of all respondents, 58.7% would elect a single-shot ISB, 15.0% would elect a continuous catheter, and 26.3% would not elect the use of an ISB if undergoing shoulder surgery. Respondents from a university hospital were 1.44 times more likely to elect any ISB than respondents from a non-university hospital. Improved post-operative pain control was considered the greatest benefit, whereas persistent neuropathy was considered the greatest risk of ISB use. Of the respondents, 76.1% would recommend use of ISB to their patients undergoing shoulder surgery. Our literature review yielded 13 applicable studies that utilized a total of 6243 ISBs, with data resulting in a 0.35% major complication rate and an 11.32% minor complication rate in patients.
The majority of shoulder surgeons surveyed in our study would elect to have a single-shot interscalene nerve block if undergoing shoulder surgery themselves, indicating that ISB use is considered a safe and effective anesthetic option among shoulder surgeon specialists.
经斜角肌间阻滞(ISB)已被证明是肩部手术中区域麻醉的有效选择。我们的研究介绍了肩部外科医生对 ISB 的看法的调查结果,以及 ISB 使用并发症发生率的文献综述。
创建了一项调查,其中包括有关 ISB 使用的人口统计学、偏好、治疗模式、风险/益处以及患者建议的问题。还询问了受访者如果亲自进行肩部手术,是否会选择 ISB,如果选择了,结果根据个人偏好进行分层。该调查通过电子方式向所有美国肩肘外科医生协会成员发送。对使用 ISB 进行肩部手术的 13 项研究进行了 ISB 相关并发症发生率的文献综述。
在所有受访者中,58.7%会选择单次注射 ISB,15.0%会选择连续导管,26.3%如果进行肩部手术,他们不会选择使用 ISB。来自大学医院的受访者选择任何 ISB 的可能性是来自非大学医院的受访者的 1.44 倍。改善术后疼痛控制被认为是 ISB 使用的最大益处,而持续性神经病变被认为是 ISB 使用的最大风险。在受访者中,76.1%会向接受肩部手术的患者推荐使用 ISB。我们的文献综述得出了 13 项适用的研究,这些研究共使用了 6243 个 ISB,数据显示患者的主要并发症发生率为 0.35%,次要并发症发生率为 11.32%。
在我们的研究中,大多数接受调查的肩部外科医生如果亲自进行肩部手术,会选择单次注射经斜角肌间神经阻滞,这表明 ISB 使用被认为是肩部外科医生专家中一种安全有效的麻醉选择。