Serebruany Victor L, Sibbing Dirk, DiNicolantonio James J
HeartDrug™ Research Laboratories, Johns Hopkins University, Towson, Md., USA.
Cardiology. 2014;127(1):20-4. doi: 10.1159/000354876. Epub 2013 Oct 26.
Oral reversible platelet P2Y12 receptor inhibitors (ticagrelor and elinogrel) cause double-digit rates of dyspnea, while irreversible oral antiplatelet drugs (aspirin, ticlopidoine, clopidogrel, and prasugrel) or intravenous glycoprotein IIb/IIIa inhibitors (abciximab, eptifibatide, or tirofiban) do not increase the incidence of dyspnea in randomized trials. Dyspnea after oral reversible antiplatelet agents remains unexplained. A transfusion-related acute lung injury (TRALI) hypothesis has been proposed. The dyspnea risks after cangrelor, an intravenous reversible antiplatelet agent, are not well defined but may offer a universal mechanism linking TRALI, dyspnea, and reversible platelet inhibition.
We analyzed safety data from recent head-to-head randomized trials with reversible antiplatelet agents (ticagrelor, elinogrel, and cangrelor) compared to irreversible (clopidogrel/placebo) comparators.
All three reversible antiplatelet agents cause excess dyspnea. In contrast to the high double-digit rates after oral ticagrelor or elinogrel, the dyspnea risks after intravenous cangrelor were smaller (<2%) but still consistently and significantly higher than in the corresponding control arms.
The clinical utility of reversible antiplatelet strategies has been challenged. Despite a potential advantage of fewer bleeding events during heart surgery, reversible antiplatelet agents carry the risk of potential autoimmune reactions manifesting as dyspnea. Repeated binding and unbinding cycles, impaired platelet turnover, and lung sequestration or apoptosis of overloaded destructive platelets are among the potential mechanism(s) responsible for dyspnea after reversible antiplatelet agents.
口服可逆性血小板P2Y12受体抑制剂(替格瑞洛和依林格雷)导致的呼吸困难发生率达两位数,而不可逆口服抗血小板药物(阿司匹林、噻氯匹定、氯吡格雷和普拉格雷)或静脉注射糖蛋白IIb/IIIa抑制剂(阿昔单抗、依替巴肽或替罗非班)在随机试验中并未增加呼吸困难的发生率。口服可逆性抗血小板药物后的呼吸困难原因仍不明。有人提出了输血相关急性肺损伤(TRALI)假说。静脉注射可逆性抗血小板药物坎格雷洛后的呼吸困难风险尚不明确,但可能提供一种将TRALI、呼吸困难和可逆性血小板抑制联系起来的通用机制。
我们分析了近期将可逆性抗血小板药物(替格瑞洛、依林格雷和坎格雷洛)与不可逆性(氯吡格雷/安慰剂)对照物进行直接对比的随机试验的安全性数据。
所有三种可逆性抗血小板药物均会导致额外的呼吸困难。与口服替格瑞洛或依林格雷后高达两位数的发生率不同,静脉注射坎格雷洛后的呼吸困难风险较小(<2%),但仍持续且显著高于相应的对照组。
可逆性抗血小板策略的临床实用性受到了挑战。尽管在心脏手术期间出血事件较少可能是一个优势,但可逆性抗血小板药物存在潜在自身免疫反应的风险,表现为呼吸困难。反复的结合和解离循环、血小板周转受损以及肺内滞留或过载破坏性血小板的凋亡是可逆性抗血小板药物后导致呼吸困难的潜在机制。