School of Chemical Engineering, South China University of Technology , Guangzhou 510640, People's Republic of China.
Environ Sci Technol. 2013 Dec 17;47(24):14450-8. doi: 10.1021/es403987k. Epub 2013 Nov 21.
Ecologically based life cycle assessment (Eco-LCA) is an appealing approach for the evaluation of resources utilization and environmental impacts of the process industries from an ecological scale. However, the aggregated metrics of Eco-LCA suffer from some drawbacks: the environmental impact metric has limited applicability; the resource utilization metric ignores indirect consumption; the renewability metric fails to address the quantitative distinction of resources availability; the productivity metric seems self-contradictory. In this paper, the existing Eco-LCA metrics are revised and extended for sustainability assessment of the energy and chemical processes. A new Eco-LCA metrics system is proposed, including four independent dimensions: environmental impact, resource utilization, resource availability, and economic effectiveness. An illustrative example of comparing assessment between a gas boiler and a solar boiler process provides insight into the features of the proposed approach.
基于生态的生命周期评估 (Eco-LCA) 是一种从生态尺度评估过程工业资源利用和环境影响的有吸引力的方法。然而,Eco-LCA 的综合指标存在一些缺点:环境影响指标的适用性有限;资源利用指标忽略了间接消耗;可再生性指标无法解决资源可用性的定量区别;生产力指标似乎自相矛盾。在本文中,对现有的 Eco-LCA 指标进行了修订和扩展,以用于能源和化工过程的可持续性评估。提出了一个新的 Eco-LCA 指标体系,包括四个独立的维度:环境影响、资源利用、资源可用性和经济有效性。通过比较燃气锅炉和太阳能锅炉工艺的评估示例,深入了解了所提出方法的特点。