Deutschlander Siegrid, Suter Esther, Grymonpre Ruby
Alberta Health Services, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Rural Remote Health. 2013 Oct-Dec;13(4):2489. Epub 2013 Nov 20.
Globally, there has been a serious health human resource (HHR) shortage for underserved populations in and outside of urban centers. This article focuses on practice education, specifically interprofessional (IP) practice education, and its impact on recruiting new health sciences graduates to populations in underserved areas as an important HHR outcome. The authors reviewed 16 articles on prelicensure practice education to identify whether (1) IP practice education is a successful recruitment strategy to for graduates to underserved communities and (2) the IP component provides an important recruitment incentive over uniprofessional practice education.
A scoping review was conducted for the time period from 2004 to 2012 yielding 1245 articles of which 16 studies were selected for this review.
Out of these 16 studies, the following HHR outcomes were reported: practice uptake by new graduates with underserved populations (eight studies), interest in working with underserved populations after graduation (eight studies), and residency requests for IP sites (three studies). These results show that IP practice education has a modest influence on recruitment to underserved areas. The impact of the IP component as an added recruitment incentive over practice education alone was not assessed in any study. Therefore, it remains uncertain whether the IP component offers an added benefit to successful recruitment.
Given the shortage of healthcare providers in rural and urban underserved populations, innovative recruitment and retention strategies to these areas must be developed and evaluated. This review of the literature suggests that IP practice education experiences offered to students may influence their first place of employment at graduation, especially in rural and urban primary care specialities involving underserved populations. The existing evidence is not strong; recommendations for future research include describing the IP practice education interventions in greater detail, designing longitudinal studies tracking all former students in such programs, and developing methodologically and theoretically rigorous intervention studies to measure the impact of the IP component as an added recruitment incentive over uniprofessional practice education experiences.
在全球范围内,城市中心内外服务不足人群面临严重的卫生人力资源短缺问题。本文聚焦于实践教育,特别是跨专业实践教育,以及其作为一项重要的卫生人力资源成果,对吸引新的健康科学专业毕业生服务于服务不足地区人群的影响。作者回顾了16篇关于执照前实践教育的文章,以确定:(1)跨专业实践教育是否是一项成功的招募策略,能吸引毕业生到服务不足社区工作;(2)跨专业组成部分相比单一专业实践教育是否能提供重要的招募激励因素。
对2004年至2012年期间进行了一项范围综述,共筛选出1245篇文章,其中16项研究被选入本综述。
在这16项研究中,报告了以下卫生人力资源成果:新毕业生为服务不足人群提供实践服务(8项研究)、毕业后对服务于服务不足人群工作的兴趣(8项研究)以及对跨专业实践地点的住院医师培训申请(3项研究)。这些结果表明,跨专业实践教育对招募毕业生到服务不足地区有一定影响。在任何研究中都未评估跨专业组成部分作为比单纯实践教育额外的招募激励因素的影响。因此,跨专业组成部分是否能为成功招募带来额外益处仍不确定。
鉴于农村和城市服务不足人群中医疗服务提供者短缺,必须制定并评估针对这些地区的创新招募和留用策略。对文献的这项综述表明,向学生提供的跨专业实践教育经历可能会影响他们毕业时的第一份工作地点,特别是在涉及服务不足人群的农村和城市初级保健专业。现有证据并不充分;对未来研究的建议包括更详细地描述跨专业实践教育干预措施、设计纵向研究跟踪此类项目中的所有往届学生,以及开展方法和理论上严谨的干预研究,以衡量跨专业组成部分作为比单一专业实践教育经历额外的招募激励因素的影响。