URI Octogone-ECCD, Pavillon de la recherche, Université de Toulouse-Le Mirail, 31 058 Toulouse Cedex 1, France.
Department of Psychology, University of Amsterdam, 1018 XA Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
J Exp Child Psychol. 2014 Apr;120:17-38. doi: 10.1016/j.jecp.2013.11.001. Epub 2013 Dec 25.
Children's understanding of universal gravitation starts at an early age but changes until adulthood, which makes it an interesting topic for studying the development and structure of knowledge. Children's understanding of gravitation was tested for a variety of contexts and across a wide age range (5-18 years, N=144). We analyzed children's predictions and justifications for the trajectory of a stone dropped on the earth, on the moon, in a spaceship orbiting the earth, on a planet with air, on a planet with no air, and in a lift (i.e., an elevator) in free fall. Results showed that performances were related to the context and to the children's age. U-shaped developmental curves were identified for predictions for three contexts. These curves could be explained by analyzing the structure of the children's knowledge using latent class analysis. We identified three coherent patterns of predictions that were related to specific justifications. With age, children produced more scientific predictions. Children's cognitive structures, as reflected in their predictions of dropped stone trajectories, seem to be coherently built given that there were only a limited number of prediction patterns. Even by Grade 12, students had not achieved a scientific understanding of universal gravitation.
儿童对万有引力的理解始于幼年,但会一直变化到成年,这使得它成为研究知识发展和结构的一个有趣话题。为了研究知识的发展和结构,研究人员测试了儿童在各种情况下对万有引力的理解,测试对象的年龄跨度很大(5-18 岁,共 144 人)。我们分析了孩子们对石头在地球上、在月球上、在绕地球飞行的宇宙飞船中、在有空气的行星上、在没有空气的行星上以及在自由落体的电梯中的下落轨迹的预测和解释。结果表明,表现与上下文和儿童年龄有关。对于三个情境的预测,发现了 U 形的发展曲线。使用潜在类别分析来分析儿童知识的结构,可以解释这些曲线。我们确定了三种与特定解释相关的一致的预测模式。随着年龄的增长,孩子们会做出更多科学的预测。从孩子们对抛石轨迹的预测中可以看出,他们的认知结构似乎是一致建立的,因为预测模式的数量有限。即使到了 12 年级,学生也没有对万有引力形成科学的理解。