Woodfield Georgia, O'Sullivan Marie, Haddington Nicholas, Stanton Andrew
University of Bristol Academy at Great Western Hospital, Swindon, Wiltshire, UK.
Clin Teach. 2014 Feb;11(1):24-8. doi: 10.1111/tct.12056.
Drug errors are a major cause of patient morbidity. The UK General Medical Council has highlighted that prescribing teaching should be prioritised. How should medical teachers best teach the practical aspects of prescribing?
We piloted a set of eight prescribing simulation tutorials for 35 final-year undergraduate medical students in Great Western Hospital, Swindon, UK. Students completed baseline questionnaires addressing confidence levels in prescribing. They then prescribed independently for simulated cases of common medical emergencies within tutor-led tutorials (n = 17) or self-directed prescribing tutorials (n = 18). Confidence scores and numbers of drug errors were documented at baseline and following four tutorials. Drug errors were categorised according to potential harm. Students then swapped to receive the alternative tutorial type.
Both tutorial types resulted in a statistically significant decrease in the number of unsafe drug errors: from 57 to three in the tutor-led group (p = 0.003) and from 60 to 14 in the self-directed learning group (p = 0.001). Both tutorial types led to statistically significant increases in confidence scores for global prescribing, prescribing in medical emergencies and managing medical emergencies (with a median increase of one point on a modified Likert scale). Confidence using the British National Formulary improved, but reached statistical significance for the self-directed group only.
Simulating cases and using real drug charts is an effective method for improving students' prescribing ability and confidence in common medical emergencies. Tutorials like these, whether tutor-led or self-directed, could be incorporated into medical curricula. This could help prevent drug errors in practice, thereby improving patient care and safety.
用药错误是导致患者发病的主要原因。英国医学总会强调,应优先进行处方教学。医学教师应如何最好地教授处方的实践方面?
我们在英国斯温顿大西部医院为35名医学本科最后一年的学生试点了一套八个处方模拟教程。学生们完成了关于处方信心水平的基线问卷。然后,他们在导师指导的教程(n = 17)或自主处方教程(n = 18)中,针对常见医疗紧急情况的模拟病例独立开出处方。记录基线时以及四个教程后的信心得分和用药错误数量。用药错误根据潜在危害进行分类。然后学生们交换接受另一种教程类型。
两种教程类型均使不安全用药错误的数量在统计学上显著减少:导师指导组从57例减少到3例(p = 0.003),自主学习组从60例减少到14例(p = 0.001)。两种教程类型均使总体处方、医疗紧急情况处方和处理医疗紧急情况的信心得分在统计学上显著提高(在改良的李克特量表上中位数提高1分)。使用《英国国家处方集》的信心有所提高,但仅自主学习组达到统计学显著性。
模拟病例并使用真实的药物处方表是提高学生在常见医疗紧急情况中的处方能力和信心的有效方法。这样的教程,无论是导师指导还是自主学习的,都可以纳入医学课程。这有助于在实践中预防用药错误,从而改善患者护理和安全。