Bhatti Junaid A, Waseem Hunniya, Razzak Junaid A, Shiekh Naeem-Ul-Lah, Khoso Ajmal Khan, Salmi L-Rachid
The Aga Khan University, Department of Emergency Medicine, PAK-74800 Karachi, Pakistan.
National Highway and Motorway Police, South Zone Office, PAK-74800 Karachi, Pakistan.
Ann Adv Automot Med. 2013;57:257-64.
Interurban road crashes often result in severe Road Traffic Injuries (RTIs). Prehospital emergency care on interurban roads was rarely evaluated in the low- and middle-income countries. The study highlighted the availability and quality of prehospital care facilities on interurban roads in Pakistan, a low-income country. The study setting was a 592-km-long National highway in the province of Sindh, Pakistan. Using the questionnaires adapted from the World Health Organization prehospital care guidelines [Sasser et al., 2005], managers and ambulance staff at the stations along highways were interviewed regarding the process of care, supplies in ambulances, and their experience of trauma care. Ambulance stations were either managed by the police or the Edhi Foundation (EF), a philanthropic organization. All highway stations were managed by the EF; the median distance between highway stations was 38 km (Interquartile Range [IQR]=27-46). We visited 14 stations, ten on the highway section, and four in cities, including two managed by the police. Most highway stations (n=13) received one RTI call per day. Half of stations (n=5) were inside highway towns, usually near primary or secondary-level healthcare facilities. Travel time to the nearest tertiary healthcare facility ranged from 31 to 70 minutes (median=48 minutes; IQR=30-60). Other shortcomings noted for stations were not triaging RTI cases (86%), informing hospitals (64%), or recording response times (57%). All ambulances (n=12) had stretchers, but only 58% had oxygen cylinders. The median schooling of ambulance staff (n=13) was 8 years (IQR=3-10), and the median paramedic training was 3 days (IQR=2-3). Observed shortcomings in prehospital care could be improved by public-private partnerships focusing on paramedic training, making available essential medical supplies, and linking ambulance stations with designated healthcare facilities for appropriate RTI triage.
城市间道路交通事故往往会导致严重的道路交通伤害(RTIs)。在低收入和中等收入国家,很少对城市间道路的院前急救进行评估。该研究强调了巴基斯坦这个低收入国家城市间道路上前急救护理设施的可用性和质量。研究地点是巴基斯坦信德省一条长592公里的国道。使用根据世界卫生组织院前护理指南改编的问卷(Sasser等人,2005年),对高速公路沿线站点的管理人员和救护人员就护理过程、救护车上的用品以及他们的创伤护理经验进行了访谈。救护站要么由警方管理,要么由慈善组织埃德希基金会(EF)管理。所有高速公路站点均由EF管理;高速公路站点之间的中位数距离为38公里(四分位间距[IQR]=27-46)。我们走访了14个站点,其中10个在高速公路路段,4个在城市,包括2个由警方管理的站点。大多数高速公路站点(n=13)每天接到1起道路交通伤害呼叫。一半的站点(n=5)位于高速公路城镇内,通常靠近初级或二级医疗保健设施。到最近的三级医疗保健设施的出行时间为31至70分钟(中位数=48分钟;IQR=30-60)。站点的其他不足之处包括未对道路交通伤害病例进行分诊(86%)、通知医院(64%)或记录响应时间(57%)。所有救护车(n=12)都有担架,但只有58%配备了氧气瓶。救护人员(n=13)的受教育年限中位数为8年(IQR=3-10),护理人员培训的中位数为3天(IQR=2-3)。通过公私合作,专注于护理人员培训、提供基本医疗用品以及将救护站与指定的医疗保健设施相连以进行适当的道路交通伤害分诊,可以改善观察到的院前护理不足之处。