Cooke Steven J, Messmer Vanessa, Tobin Andrew J, Pratchett Morgan S, Clark Timothy D
Fish Ecology and Conservation Physiology Laboratory, Department of Biology and Institute of Environmental Science, Carleton University, 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa, Ontario K1S 5B6, Canada; 2Australian Research Council Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies, James Cook University, Townsville, Queensland 4811, Australia; 3Centre for Sustainable Tropical Fisheries and Aquaculture and School of Earth and Environmental Sciences, James Cook University, Townsville, Queensland 4811, Australia; 4Australian Institute of Marine Science, PMB 3, Townsville MC, Queensland 4810, Australia.
Physiol Biochem Zool. 2014 Jan-Feb;87(1):136-47. doi: 10.1086/671166. Epub 2013 Jun 26.
Fisheries and marine park management strategies for large predatory reef fish can mean that a large proportion of captured fish are released. Despite being released, these fish may experience high mortality while they traverse the water column to locate suitable refuge to avoid predators, all the while recovering from the stress of capture. The predatory reef fish Spanish flag snapper (Lutjanus carponotatus) is frequently released because of a minimum-size or bag limit or by fishers targeting more desirable species. Using L. carponotatus as a model, we tested whether simulated fishing stress (exercise and air exposure) resulted in impairments in reflexes (e.g., response to stimuli) and the ability to identify and use refuge in a laboratory arena and whether any impairments were associated with blood physiology or metabolic recovery. Control fish were consistently responsive to reflex tests and rapidly located and entered refugia in the arena within seconds. Conversely, treatment fish (exhausted and air exposed) were unresponsive to stimuli, took longer to search for refugia, and were more apprehensive to enter the refuge once it was located. Consequently, treatment fish took more than 70 times longer than control fish to enter the coral refuge (26.12 vs. 0.36 min, respectively). The finding that fish exposed to stress were hesitant to use refugia suggests that there was likely cognitive, visual, and/or physiological impairment. Blood lactate, glucose, and hematocrit measures were perturbed at 15 and 30 min after the stressor, relative to controls. However, measurements of oxygen consumption rate revealed that about 50% of metabolic recovery occurred within 30 min after the stressor, coinciding with apparent cognitive/visual/physiological recovery. Recovering the treatment fish in aerated, flow-through chambers for 30 min before introduction to the behavioral arena restored reflexes, and "recovered" fish behaved more similarly to controls. Therefore, we suggest that temporarily holding coral reef fish that have undergone an exhaustive fishing interaction and an air exposure episode should enable significant recovery of cognitive and metabolic attributes that would enable fish to more rapidly locate and utilize refugia to avoid postrelease predation. However, after nonexhaustive fishing interactions (i.e., minimal reflex impairment), it is likely that immediate release would be most beneficial.
针对大型掠食性珊瑚礁鱼类的渔业和海洋公园管理策略可能意味着很大一部分捕获的鱼会被放生。尽管被放生,但这些鱼在穿过水柱寻找合适的避难所以躲避捕食者的过程中可能会经历高死亡率,同时还要从被捕捞的压力中恢复过来。掠食性珊瑚礁鱼类西班牙旗笛鲷(Lutjanus carponotatus)经常因最小尺寸限制或渔获量限制而被放生,或者被渔民放生,因为渔民的目标是更受欢迎的物种。以西班牙旗笛鲷为模型,我们测试了模拟捕捞压力(运动和空气暴露)是否会导致反射(如对刺激的反应)受损,以及在实验室环境中识别和利用避难所的能力受损,以及任何损伤是否与血液生理学或代谢恢复有关。对照鱼对反射测试始终有反应,并在几秒钟内迅速在实验环境中找到并进入避难所。相反,处理组的鱼(精疲力竭且暴露在空气中)对刺激无反应,寻找避难所的时间更长,一旦找到避难所,进入避难所时也更加犹豫。因此,处理组的鱼进入珊瑚避难所的时间比对照鱼长70多倍(分别为26.12分钟和0.36分钟)。暴露于压力下的鱼对使用避难所犹豫不决这一发现表明,可能存在认知、视觉和/或生理损伤。相对于对照组,应激源施加后15分钟和30分钟时,血液乳酸、葡萄糖和血细胞比容测量值受到干扰。然而,耗氧率测量显示,约50%的代谢恢复发生在应激源施加后30分钟内,这与明显的认知/视觉/生理恢复相吻合。在将处理组的鱼引入行为实验环境之前,在充气的流通池中恢复30分钟可恢复反射,“恢复”后的鱼行为与对照组更相似。因此,我们建议,暂时收留经历过彻底捕捞互动和空气暴露事件的珊瑚礁鱼类,应能使认知和代谢属性得到显著恢复,使鱼能够更迅速地找到并利用避难所,以避免放生后的捕食。然而,在经历非彻底捕捞互动(即反射损伤最小)后,立即放生可能最为有益。