Hu Daniel, Juarez Deborah Taira, Yeboah Michelle, Castillo Theresa P
University of Hawai'i at Hilo; Hilo, HI (DH, DTJ).
Hawaii J Med Public Health. 2014 Jan;73(1):11-8.
The objective of this systematic review was to investigate the effectiveness of interventions to improve medication adherence in ethnic minority populations. A literature search from January 2000 to August 2012 was conducted through PubMed/Medline, Web of Science, The Cochrane Library, and Google Scholar. Search terms used included: medication (MeSH), adherence, medication adherence (MeSH), compliance (MeSH), persistence, race, ethnicity, ethnic groups (MeSH), minority, African-American, Hispanic, Latino, Asian, Pacific Islander, and intervention. Studies which did not have ≥75% of the sample population comprised of individuals of any one ethnic background were excluded, unless the authors performed sub-group analyses by race/ethnicity. Of the 36 studies identified, 20 studies showed significant post-intervention differences. Sample population sizes ranged from 10 to 520, with a median of 126.5. The studies in this review were conducted with patients of mainly African-American and Latino descent. No studies were identified which focused on Asians, Pacific Islanders, or Native Americans. Interventions demonstrating mixed results included motivational interviewing, reminder devices, community health worker (CHW) delivered interventions, and pharmacist-delivered interventions. Directly observed therapy (DOT) was a successful intervention in two studies. Interventions which did not involve human contact with patients were ineffective. In this literature review, studies varied significantly in their methods and design as well as the populations studied. There was a lack of congruence among studies in the way adherence was measured and reported. No single intervention has been seen to be universally successful, particularly for patients from ethnic minority backgrounds.
本系统评价的目的是调查改善少数民族人群药物依从性干预措施的有效性。通过PubMed/Medline、科学网、考克兰图书馆和谷歌学术搜索了2000年1月至2012年8月的文献。使用的检索词包括:药物(医学主题词)、依从性、药物依从性(医学主题词)、顺应性(医学主题词)、持续性、种族、民族、族群(医学主题词)、少数群体、非裔美国人、西班牙裔、拉丁裔、亚裔、太平洋岛民和干预。样本人群中任何一个种族背景的个体占比不足75%的研究被排除,除非作者按种族/民族进行亚组分析。在检索到的36项研究中,20项研究显示干预后有显著差异。样本量从10到520不等,中位数为126.5。本评价中的研究主要针对非裔美国人和拉丁裔后裔患者开展。未发现针对亚裔、太平洋岛民或美洲原住民的研究。显示出混合结果的干预措施包括动机性访谈、提醒装置、由社区卫生工作者实施的干预措施以及由药剂师实施的干预措施。直接观察治疗(DOT)在两项研究中是成功的干预措施。不涉及与患者人际接触的干预措施无效。在这篇文献综述中,各项研究在方法、设计以及所研究的人群方面差异很大。在依从性的测量和报告方式上,研究之间缺乏一致性。尚未发现单一干预措施普遍有效,尤其是对来自少数民族背景的患者。