Wang Jian, Guan Wenhua, Chen Diansen, Han Yan, Xu Zhibin, Qiang Jun, Chen Wang, Li Na, Gao Wanqin
Department of Radiology, First Affiliated Hospital of Henan University of Technology, Luoyang, 471003, China.
Cell Biochem Biophys. 2014 Jul;69(3):517-22. doi: 10.1007/s12013-014-9826-6.
The value of computed tomography pulmonary angiography (CTPA) for the diagnosis of right ventricular dysfunction (RVD) subsequent to acute pulmonary embolism (PE). The ultrasonic cardiography (UCG) was used to assess RVD, one of the diagnostic criteria of PE caused hemodynamic collapse. Seventy six patients with confirmed PE were divided into massive (52 cases) and non-massive PE group (24 cases). The diagnostic criteria assessed for the imminent RVD were: (1) the ratio of axial diameters of the right and left ventricular chambers (RVd/LVd) exceeding 1, or (2) the right ventricular end-diastolic diameter measuring >30 mm. The CTPA diagnosed RVD was positive in 36 and negative in 40 cases. The RVD assessed by UCG was positive in 31 and negative in 45 cases. In comparison to UCG, the CTPA results UCG exhibited 96.77 % sensitivity 96.77 % and 86.67 specificity. The evaluated values both of these techniques were found in good agreement by the kappa value (κ) of 0.81, P < 0.001. In 52 cases of massive PE, CTPA determined RVD was positive in 34, and negative in 18 cases. In comparison, UCG diagnosed RVD was positive in 31 and negative in 21 cases. The sensitivity and specificity of CTPA results compared to those of UCG were 91.18 and 85.71 %, respectively. The estimates obtained were in good agreement as indicated by 0.88 κ value and P < 0.001. Twenty four cases of non-massive PE were RVD negative when assessed by CTPA, UCG however showed two cases positive in this group. Compared to UCG, the specificity of CTPA in evaluating RVD was 100 %. In the massive PE group, the average estimate of RVd/LVd ratio was significantly higher than 1 as analyzed by the non-parametric Mann-Whitney test (P < 0.001). The CTPA and UCG results showed a good correlation in massive PE cases. However, in non-massive PE group, results from two techniques were not correlated. The CTPA can accurately and reliably diagnose the PE and ensuing by estimating changes in the anatomical parameters of right ventricle. Hence, it can allow prompt diagnosis and an appropriate treatment leading to an improved prognosis.
计算机断层扫描肺动脉造影(CTPA)对急性肺栓塞(PE)后右心室功能障碍(RVD)的诊断价值。采用超声心动图(UCG)评估RVD,这是PE导致血流动力学崩溃的诊断标准之一。76例确诊为PE的患者分为大面积PE组(52例)和非大面积PE组(24例)。评估即将发生RVD的诊断标准为:(1)右心室与左心室腔内径之比(RVd/LVd)超过1,或(2)右心室舒张末期直径测量值>30 mm。CTPA诊断RVD阳性36例,阴性40例。UCG评估RVD阳性31例,阴性45例。与UCG相比,CTPA结果显示敏感性为96.77%,特异性为86.67%。这两种技术的评估值经kappa值(κ)为0.81,P<0.001,显示出良好的一致性。在52例大面积PE患者中,CTPA确定RVD阳性34例,阴性18例。相比之下,UCG诊断RVD阳性31例,阴性21例。CTPA结果与UCG结果相比,敏感性和特异性分别为91.18%和85.71%。所得估计值经κ值0.88和P<0.001表明具有良好的一致性。24例非大面积PE患者经CTPA评估RVD为阴性,但UCG显示该组有2例阳性。与UCG相比,CTPA评估RVD的特异性为100%。在大面积PE组中,经非参数Mann-Whitney检验分析,RVd/LVd比值的平均估计值显著高于l(P<0.001)。在大面积PE病例中,CTPA和UCG结果显示出良好的相关性。然而,在非大面积PE组中,两种技术的结果不相关。CTPA可以通过估计右心室解剖参数的变化准确可靠地诊断PE及其继发情况。因此,它可以实现及时诊断和适当治疗,从而改善预后。